T206 Red Cobb or T206 Red Cobb?

[Leon]

I picked up what I think might be an upgrade for me but want to get others thoughts too. Which would you choose and why? Of course both look pretty nice but I am biased...Only one will (probably ) stay.
And remember, I am one who likes big borders.
Sorry for the different size scans... ALso, the 1.5 has some spider wrinkles as can be seen.

[bnorth]

PSA card all day. The main 2 reasons are I like the background to be dark red, not orangeish. I also like Ty to be looking to the left, not to the right when facing me.

PSA 1.5 without a doubt. Better color, better image, sharper corners. And with the money you get from selling the SGC 4 you can buy more stuff!

[Stampsfan]

The 1.5 looks short on both top and bottom in the holder, while the 4 looks like it fits slightly better.

Hard to tell tho when they are not to scale with each other.

Which one measures out larger?

[jburl]

Tough call. Image/color obviously better on the 1.5, but I'm a sucker for polar bear tobacco stains and reasonably-rounded corners.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

[BeanTown]

If both cards raw, the 350 back one gets my vote as the registry is better. Now, you have to figure out why each card got accessed the grade they did. Especially the PSA card, as I have no trust in them whatsoever when it comes to high dollar cards. If you are sold in bith cards, then go to the more rarer backside to own.

[RCMcKenzie]

Both are nice examples. I voted for the Polar Bear. You could always start a Red Cobb back-run...Rob

[JeremyW]

I like the clarity of the Sweet Caporal.

[Rhotchkiss]

PSA 1.5 looks short. Just sayin.

That said, I will go with the rarer back every day of the week

[Leon]

Thanks for the responses so far. I don't think either is trimmed and most likely the PB is larger than the Sweet Cap. I don't have the PB in hand yet as I just acquired it (from a reputable seller).
I do like big borders..

[Jstottlemire1]

Thanks and appreciated. I’m sure others have said the same but if not put me on the list both are great cards!!!

[Jstottlemire1]

This being said a more rare back, it’s in a better slab both in terms of grade and the black background and as well all know pbs in the pack coming out looking that phenomenal is great. Should be proud to own both.

[jcc6252]

I'd go with the Sweet Cap, truer red background (as mentioned previously), and better bang for the buck. Leon, I believe you be the Master at spotting low grade gems.

I find this so interesting. I mean there is literally nothing more appealing about the PB aside from the back and the technical grade. PB backs aren't even particularly rare either. Great sociological study here, particularly for a board whose generic mantra is to buy the card not the grade

[TUM301]

For me it`s the PSA 1.5 Sweet Cap. Just has an overall sharper appearance than the P Bear. As said would enjoy owning either but if it`s one, the S Cap.

[charlietheexterminator]

I love that Sweet Caporal 1.5, it stands out strong, the deep red is incredible, the card appearance looks much better than the given grade, isn’t that what we all look for...

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by bnorth

PSA card all day. The main 2 reasons are I like the background to be dark red, not orangeish. I also like Ty to be looking to the left, not to the right when facing me.

Yes, this also...

[SikSyko]

I would say the Polar Bear back, but that is because I love those backs.

[rats60]

Originally Posted by Gobucsmagic74

I find this so interesting. I mean there is literally nothing more appealing about the PB aside from the back and the technical grade. PB backs aren't even particularly rare either. Great sociological study here, particularly for a board whose generic mantra is to buy the card not the grade

I don't like creases. The creases on the face of the Sweet Cap would drive me crazy. The PB is far more appealing to me if I had to pick one.

[DeanH3]

I'm a big border guy too. So I'd prefer the PB. The SC is nothing to snicker at. Maybe keep both for now. As you know, you'll have no trouble selling either one if/when.

[Ronnie73]

I voted Polar Bear. Polar Bears may seem common to some but once you get into the 4 and up grades, they become more difficult. If the Sweet Caporal was a lower population Factory 25, then it would be a much more difficult choice for me.

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by Ronnie73

I voted Polar Bear. Polar Bears may seem common to some but once you get into the 4 and up grades, they become more difficult. If the Sweet Caporal was a lower population Factory 25, then it would be a much more difficult choice for me.

^^^^^spot on

[obcmac]

I vote PB also. I view the 4 grade as a detriment, not an asset...as the less money I have in, the more I like it. That said, the combination of large borders and natural PB staining give me assurances that the 1.5 doesn't. Both great in any case.

[bounce]

PB for me - let me know when you're ready to get rid of it

[Steve D]

I like the color and image quality of the PSA card a little better; and I don't really like that light spot just below Ty's neck on the SGC one.

Even with the above, however, I prefer the SGC card, overall, to the PSA one; mainly due to the larger borders. Like you indicated in your post, Leon, I also prefer larger borders; and even if not trimmed, the PSA card's top/bottom borders are a bit too narrow for my taste.

Plus, I really do not like creases.

Steve

[orly57]

Here is a side by side. I have to say, I like the PSA better (on left). The color, registration, and corners are just better. Leon, you could probably make this pic bigger.

Originally Posted by orly57

Here is a side by side. I have to say, I like the PSA better (on left). The color, registration, and corners are just better. Leon, you could probably make this pic bigger.

Agreed. Polar Bear back isn't that special. Sorry, its just not. The aesthetics are so much better on the PSA in pretty much every possible way. No one could possibly deny that without the graded slabs

[whelenfan]

the side by side pics really bring out the qualities of the PSA card! it does seem to look much better.

[Rhotchkiss]

Orlando!!! Great to hear from you. How are you?

The side by side pic is helpful. The PSA looks nicer, but it also looks much shorter. Confirming my vote for the bigger borders and rarer back

[MVSNYC]

PB for sure. The SC is short (not saying trimmed, but annoyingly short), and a diamond cut (which always irritates me).

[Leon]

Apparently members can't see. They should be graders. The 1.5 is actually larger than most. It isn't short.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by Leon

Apparently members can't see. They should be graders. The 1.5 is actually larger than most. It isn't short.

That PB must be huge. I couldn't get them to line up perfect and the PB scan is about .5 percent smaller and still has noticeably larger borders.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by bnorth

That PB must be huge. I couldn't get them to line up perfect and the PB scan is about .5 percent smaller and still has noticeably larger borders.

It is huge. That is why I bought it. Kind of like all of the ones I posted. I might just keep both for now

[luciobar1980]

I think the PSA card looks nicer in most respects except that the red seems to have a little haze/white noise sorta stuff going on.

[Fred]

Originally Posted by Leon

It is huge. That is why I bought it. Kind of like all of the ones I posted. I might just keep both for now

And just how sharp are those scissors?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Fred

And just how sharp are those scissors?

I could see the 4 getting into a higher holder albeit with a bit less borders. It is safe as long as I own it.

and thanks to all who commented or voted.

.

[irishdenny]

Originally Posted by Leon

I could see the 4 getting into a higher holder albeit with a bit less borders. It is safe as long as I own it.

and thanks to all who commented or voted.

.

Jus Grand!
So it's Settled Then...
Mr Cobb Polar Bear it is!!!

i actually would need to see the Sweet Mr Cobb in hand!
i jus Don't Trust PSA Cards At All ~
Even from San Antonio wit a Ruff Scan,
For me... Mr Cobb's Bottom Left Corner has that "I MiGHT of been Trimmed Look!?"

Polar Bear All Day Long fir me Leon ~