Cards that never were....what would you have liked to see?

[Golfcollector]

As a collector of various cards and sports over the years, I have many times wondered why a particular person did NOT appear in a certain set or series of cards.

Not sure if this has been discussed before, but though I would ask, what are some of the 'Cards that never were" of someone that you would have like to have seen produced.
(can be any sport)

Since this is my thread...I will mention two.

Baseball - I would have to say a T205 Sam Crawford. This was the height of his playing days, a beautiful issue, yet sadly...no T205 Wahoo.

As a collector of golf Cards, a 1930 W.D and H.O. Wills - Bobby Jones. They picked Walter Hagen for the issue, but not Jones oddly enough, as by then Walter was pretty much done with highly competitive golf. This was Jones' grand slam year and he was one of the main figures in all of sport much less golf.

Would like to hear your nominations.

[Leon]

1934 Goudey Ruth.....(and not a premium, a regular card)

[BradH]

1951 Bowman Stan Musial and 1952-58 Topps Musial. Has always bugged me that he's not in these sets (he does have a '58 Topps All-Star card, but not a regular issue).

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

T205 Joe Jackson

[jasonc]

T206 Joe Jackson; either portrait or action pose. I bet it would be an expensive card!

[Bigshot69]

Originally Posted by Leon

1934 Goudey Ruth.....(and not a premium, a regular card)

This is a significant gap in the set but do you feel the exclusion of Ruth adds to the desirability of his 4 cards in the 33 set while also increasing the prestige of the #57 Gehrig, the key card to the 34 set?

[jasonc]

Originally Posted by BradH

1951 Bowman Stan Musial and 1952-58 Topps Musial. Has always bugged me that he's not in these sets (he does have a '58 Topps All-Star card, but not a regular issue).

Brad, good choice!

Man, if Musial was in 1952 Topps, that would've been an iconic card!

[jmb]

1915 CJ Ruth, 34 Goudey Ruth, 51 Bowman Joe DiMaggio

[mechanicalman]

33 Delong Babe Ruth
33 Tatoo Orbit Ruth and Gehrig
33 George C Miller Ruth and Gehrig
34 Goudey Mel Ott
E93, 95, or 98 Walter Johnson
T205 Lajoie

[irv]

1952 Topps, Ted Williams, Ralph Kiner, Satchel Paige, Whitey Ford, Nellie Fox, Don Newcomb and of course, Stan Musial.
Dimaggio is another one, although he announced his retirement before the start of the 52 Topps production.

[rats60]

To add to what's here, Honus Wagner in t sets other than t206. 1952T, in addition to Musial, Ted Williams, Ralph Kiner and Satchel Paige. 1953 Bowman was such a beautiful set, but too small. More Hofers including Williams, Mays and Paige. Same for1954 and 1955 Topps, specifically Mantle.

[e107collector]

Originally Posted by jasonc

T206 Joe Jackson; either portrait or action pose. I bet it would be an expensive card!

T-206 Joe Jackson portrait would be unbelievable!! imho

CJ Ruth, T205 Wagner

Tony

[irv]

Originally Posted by irv

1952 Topps, Ted Williams, Ralph Kiner, Satchel Paige, Whitey Ford, Nellie Fox, Don Newcomb and of course, Stan Musial.
Dimaggio is another one, although he announced his retirement before the start of the 52 Topps production.

Originally Posted by rats60

To add to what's here, Honus Wagner in t sets other than t206. 1952T, in addition to Musial, Ted Williams, Ralph Kiner and Satchel Paige. 1953 Bowman was such a beautiful set, but too small. More Hofers including Williams, Mays and Paige. Same for1954 and 1955 Topps, specifically Mantle.

Beat ya to it, Rats.

There are more listed here but I guess they have to draw the line somewhere.
http://www.1952toppsbaseballcards.com/

[Bigshot69]

How about a ‘41 Play Ball Satchel Paige KC Monarchs mail in short print?

[edjs]

T211 Joe Jackson

[SMPEP]

1923 W572 Walt Barbare ... oh, wait ... it "exists". ;-)

[trdcrdkid]

T205 or T207 Grover Cleveland Alexander.

[jbl79]

1933 Goudey Josh Gibson
1933 Goudey Satchel Paige
1933 Goudey Greenberg
1934-36 Diamond Stars Ruth
1934-36 Diamond Stars Gehrig
1938 Goudey Gehrig
1939 Play Ball Gehrig
1941 Play Ball Musial
1948 Bowman Williams
1949 Bowman Williams

...and its been mentioned but would've loved to have seen a 52 Topps and 53 Bowman Color Ted Williams.

[rats60]

Originally Posted by irv

Beat ya to it, Rats.

There are more listed here but I guess they have to draw the line somewhere.
http://www.1952toppsbaseballcards.com/

~3 minutes. You posted while I was typing my list. At least great minds think alike. How great would the 400+ card 1952 Topps set be if it actually included all the best players of that time? Especially the 2 best players in the game at the time.

[sflayank]

1968 topps 3d mickey mantle
1955 armour coins of jackie and campy

[Piratedogcardshows]

For me it would be

T210 & T209-2 Jim Thorpe
T210 Cowan Richmond same pose as his T209 will do!

[cdn_collector]

First thing that comes to mind for me is a Cracker Jack George Gibson.
Sure wish he was in one (or both) of those sets.

Cheers,

Richard.

[avery1328]

1957 Killebrew

[rhettyeakley]

The two I would love to see...

T209-2 Jim Thorpe
Zeenut Ted Williams (Doerr too I suppose)

[judsonhamlin]

Old Judge Frank Grant
Batter Up Gehrig
33 Goudey Mack
50 Bowman Al Simmons

[oldjudge]

1890 Old Judge Player’s League John Ward

[felada]

OJ Fleetwood walker and one arm daily. N173 spotted ties and browns champs

Mayo cy young

[paul]

1948-51 Bowman Joe DiMaggio
1948-55 Bowman Hal Newhouser
1939-40 Play Ball Dizzy Dean with Cubs
So many other Play Balls, like Appling, Billy Herman, Gabby Hartnett, 1939 Foxx and Gehrig, etc.

[bnorth]

Like has already been mentioned a Ted Williams in the sets he is missing from. Here is a custom 52 Topps Ted Williams made by a fellow member. It is one of the nicest I have seen.

[MacDice]

1957 Jackie Robinson in a giants uniform

[bobbvc]

T206 Wagner action shot. Also a T204, T205 and T3 Wagner.

[bobbvc]

T206 team cards would have been pretty neat also. Although probably hard to recognize individual players.

[brianp-beme]

Originally Posted by bobbvc

T206 team cards would have been pretty neat also. Although probably hard to recognize individual players.

I think T3 team cards would be a great size and would be really interesting to see.

Brian

[ksfarmboy]

1955/1956 Brooks Robinson
T206 Joe Wood

[JollyElm]

This would've been nice...

1972williemaystraded2small.jpg

[boneheadandrube]

T218 Baseball series or more T227 Baseball subjects. A t204 Cobb and Matty would be something also...

[Steve D]

1936/37 Zeenut Ted Williams!


Steve

[glynparson]

1951 Bowman Eddie Gaedel
1965 Satchel Paige
1946 sports exchange Pete Gray

I guess either the Handel or Paige could have been one year later in which case make it a 1952 topps Eddie Gaedel, sports exchange is multiple years so it would still apply


Also diamond star Ruth and Gehrig and 1934 goudey Ruth.

[Rich Falvo]

Like many others, I'd love to see the missing Williams, Mantle, and Musial cards from 52-56. Williams especially - like others whose careers overlapped the wars, he has relatively few cards for such a long career.

[paul]

One other card that would have been nice would be a 1947 Tip Top of Willard Brown with the St. Louis Browns.

[cardcountry]

54 Topps Mantle
55 Topps Mantle
52 Topps Williams
34 Goudey Ruth

[aljurgela]

Negro league card actually issued in America. While I love all the Latin. Cards, it always makes me sad to think that all the amazing players were never commerated in USA cardboard. Imagine... Gibson, Paige, Wells’s, leoanard, Williams.... etc. WOW.

[Baseball Rarities]

Originally Posted by aljurgela

Negro league card actually issued in America. While I love all the Latin. Cards, it always makes me sad to think that all the amazing players were never commerated in USA cardboard. Imagine... Gibson, Paige, Wells’s, leoanard, Williams.... etc. WOW.

+1 The only thing that we really have are the early 1930’s Harrison Real Photo Postcards and they are certainly not a prototypical baseball card.

[sago]

N173 Cap Anson in Uniform
Ty Cobb back cards of his 3 other T-206's

[boneheadandrube]

A 1914-15 Cracker Jack mail-in premium set of some kind. In color print on something like M110 paper stock. Oooh..

[Andrew1975]

T206 Tris Speaker portrait
T206 Smoky Joe Wood

[Vintageclout]

Here's my wish list in no particular order of significance although I think a majority of the hobby would agree that the most incredible card would be a 1915 Cracker Jack Babe Ruth "true" rookie card.

Joe T.

1915 CJ Ruth
1933 DeLong Ruth
1934 Goudey Ruth
T206 Jackson
T206 Speaker w/M116 Portrait Pose
T204 Cobb, Wagner & Matty
E94 Matty & Jackson
T227 Matty, WoJo & Jackson (wow...those would be amazing!)
E126 Gehrig
Various major "E" cards of Walter Johnson

[bobbyw8469]

1954 Topps Mantle.

[bbcard1]

Agreed on the 1954 and 1955 Topps Mantle. One that I would like to see is a 1963 Topps Maury Wills. Not only was it a significant and revolutionary season, I have met Wills a few times and have found him to be nice and courteous, which is the opposite of his described persona.

[judsonhamlin]

Also

T222 Speaker, Mathewson & Lajoie