Auction Loser Sour Grapes

[T206Collector]

To Whomever Beat Me For The Signed 1915 Cracker Jack Marquard Last Night:

I guess you should be congratulated, but really... What were you thinking? You just paid $2,700 for a Rube Marquard autograph. I'm pretty sure you broke the record. Are signed CJ's rare? You bet. There are only a few known, but guess what... Three of those are Marquards, and this one isn't even the best example. Also, you should know that no one was willing to bid more than $1,200 for this card than me. That's right... The only bidder bidding into your outrageous ceiling bid was me. So, if and when you try to sell this beauty, you had better hope I am still interested. And since I just paid $100 for a signed M101-2 Marquard -- the only one known -- I think I'll probably just sit that one out.

In closing, I want to say that I hope you enjoy your latest cardboard treasure, and appreciate it half as much as I would have, which I am certain will be at least twice as much as you will. Fortunately, I am now $2,500 richer, and can put that money toward some pretty sweet cards.

All the best,
Sour Grapes Underbidder



p.s. Feel free to email me if you ever want to sell it or trade it.

[slidekellyslide]

Why did you bid it up to $2500 if it wasn't worth it?

[phikappapsi]

Sounds like 2 people just bid up a market that only the two of them were in... Smrt

[barrysloate]

Two people bidding up an item to a crazy level is a time honored hobby tradition. Nothing new here.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by phikappapsi

Sounds like 2 people just bid up a market that only the two of them were in... Smrt

I have done that more times than I can count....and so have many collectors on this board.

[phikappapsi]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Two people bidding up an item to a crazy level is a time honored hobby tradition. Nothing new here.

Fair enough

[sebie43]

Yea, go get em buddy

[bn2cardz]

This made me laugh because I have felt this way about cards sometimes. I especially like the end when you say you may not want it, but he go ahead and contact me if you want to sell.

Originally Posted by T206Collector

So, if and when you try to sell this beauty, you had better hope I am still interested. And since I just paid $100 for a signed M101-2 Marquard -- the only one known -- I think I'll probably just sit that one out.

All the best,
Sour Grapes Underbidder



p.s. Feel free to email me if you ever want to sell it or trade it.

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

Why did you bid it up to $2500 if it wasn't worth it?

I think the OP was being Tongue-in-cheek. I am sure he is upset that he didn't win, but based off his winky smile I think he knows that it is just what he said it was "sour grapes"

[wolf441]

I took the post as completely tongue in cheek. I've felt the same way many times in the past. You keep plugging in bids saying to yourself "really??!!" "WTF??!!". Hopefully the winning bidder feels as passionately about the card as the OP.

I remember feeling the same way about a T206 Piedmont 350-460 Factory 42 that I thought I was sneaking up on because of the way it was listed on ebay. I felt much better afterwards though when I found out who won it.

[batsballsbases]

I will use my line that I always use "Its the P.T. Barnum theory my friends"

[T206Collector]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

Why did you bid it up to $2500 if it wasn't worth it?

Oh, that card is definitely worth $2,500 ....but not a penny more!

I hate losing out on cards that I was willing to overpay by hundreds or thousands of dollars on. Hate it, hate it, hate it.

I wanted to capture the emotion of that -- while also acknowledging that I was being totally hypocritical.

[phikappapsi]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

Oh, that card is definitely worth $2,500 ....but not a penny more!

I hate losing out on cards that I was willing to overpay by hundreds or thousands of dollars on. Hate it, hate it, hate it.

I wanted to capture the emotion of that -- while also acknowledging that I was being totally hypocritical.

Achieved.

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

Oh, that card is definitely worth $2,500 ....but not a penny more!

I hate losing out on cards that I was willing to overpay by hundreds or thousands of dollars on. Hate it, hate it, hate it.

I wanted to capture the emotion of that -- while also acknowledging that I was being totally hypocritical.

I hear ya...I once bid $700 on a Nebraska Indians cover letter, and was astounded that I got outbid...and I'm pretty sure I even told myself that it wasn't worth anywhere near that.

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

Oh, that card is definitely worth $2,500 ....but not a penny more!

I hate losing out on cards that I was willing to overpay by hundreds or thousands of dollars on. Hate it, hate it, hate it.

I wanted to capture the emotion of that -- while also acknowledging that I was being totally hypocritical.

If people are being totally honest with themselves you are capturing how many under-bidders feel.

[T206Collector]

I guess Ted finally took pity on me -- thanks for keeping me in mind when it was time to move this beauty on...

[insccollectibles]

I have to say I feel your pain. I recently lost a card I would have Cherished for many years to a reseller. It does not feel good but hopefully another Snodgrass great find will come along for you. The thrill of victory and the agony of defeat so true for vintage collectors.

[btcarfagno]

Originally Posted by ins02

I have to say I feel your pain. I recently lost a card I would have Cherished for many years to a reseller. It does not feel good but hopefully another Snodgrass great find will come along for you. The thrill of victory and the agony of defeat so true for vintage collectors.

Speaking of the Snodgrass great find I have a bunch of sour grapes over that little S.O.B. I was underbidder in the REA auction lot it was in....and it was the only card in the lot I wanted. Then the dumbass who outbid me turns around and BIN's a thousand dollar card for $150? Really? Sour Sour Sour F'n Grapes.

Bah!!

Tom C

[BeanTown]

Alot of interesting action last night in Legendary?!?! Seems I was pushed up on 2 Cleveland schedules from 1913 and 1914. Had to let someone else win the currency lot that was not described that good. Heck, I got pushed up on a bi-fold Michigan fottball postcard...seems like most stuff I bidded on or had higher reserve bids on, had late action that went well past midnight... Strange

[atx840]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

I guess Ted finally took pity on me

I wish he would take pity on me

Nice card!

[Exhibitman]

Nice! Now go outside and chase those pesky kids off your lawn.

[Runscott]

As Barry said 9 months ago, the 'card-lust 2 bidder' thing is a common and cherished part of our hobby. Some of our greatest stories come from such events. I've been involved in some of those, but oddly, can only remember winning one. Still, it's been fun to watch others involved in those dogfights at two in the morning. More than a few times I've gone to bed scratching my head.

Glad to hear you finally got your Marquard - probably makes you appreciate it that much more.

[ALR-bishop]

When I win a scarce item at a price higher than I was hoping to pay, I just think, "bet that son of a gun wished had bid higher, hah".

If I lose it I just think, "I bet that son of a gun is pretty mad about having to pay so much, hah "