Cards that never seem to come up for sale

[packs]

I've got a nice chunk of change saved up that I'm dying to spend on cards I've always wanted. The problem is, they never seem to come up for sale. I'd kill for a low grade Joe Jackson M101-4 or a low grade Honus Cracker Jack. An E95 Honus in a 1 or 2 with great eye appeal? Where are you!? I'd do anything for the chance to buy a PSA/SGC 2 Collins-McCarthy Tris Speaker. If only someone had one.

What are some cards you've been wanting to add to your collection that never seem to come up for sale?

[bcbgcbrcb]

E254 Joe McCarthy in decent condition

[HRBAKER]

W503 Frisch and other HOFers

[HercDriver]

I've been waiting for a T205 Beck and Bender to show up, although they may not even exist. They are the last two that I have on my "suspected, but not seen" list. I also have been jonesing for a Bescher, which I saw, but didn't buy at the time...

Take Care,
Geno

[packs]

We aren't asking for a lot are we?

[bcbgcbrcb]

Should have also mentioned, any career contemporary photo/card/postcard picturing Negro Leaguers, Turkey Stearnes, Willie Foster & Frank Grant.

[z28jd]

Lave Cross Old Judge card. He is on my original wantlist I made before I ever bought a single OJ card back when I was a teenager. Nearly 20 years later, I can't recall ever having a chance to bid on one, definitely hasn't shown up anytime recent that I've seen.

[atx840]

Carolina Brights or Broad Leaf backed Solly Hofman....come on peoples....let them be free.

[wolf441]

It's been awhile since I've seen a low grade T206 Drum back that was up for bid in a real (no reserve/buy it now/ridiculously high opening) auction. Although, truth be told, I've only recently started joining the non-ebay auction houses (thanks Net54!! ). So I may just not be looking hard enough!

[rp12367]

T210 Kelly Mascot

[E93]

If I told you, I would have to kill you.
JimB

[Piratedogcardshows]

Old Judge Jake Wells.Im not sure I could even afford it but I haven't seen one for sale before.Very interesting life story.A dream card for sure.

[z28jd]

Originally Posted by Jason

Old Judge Jake Wells.Im not sure I could even afford it but I haven't seen one for sale before.Very interesting life story.A dream card for sure.

He is another card that doesn't come up, along with about 50 other OJ players. Just like with the Cross, it will go for big bucks when it does show up just because we haven't seen one recently. Try finding a Taylor Shaffer, my good friend Kevin will tell you that you shouldn't let one of these tough players get away, even if it isn't the player you're looking for, you could always try to use it as trade bait. I would love to get a William Veach OJ but I've never even put it on my wantlist for a reason, I'm not going to be able to afford it if it does come up

[npa589]

T207 saier/ward miller...............................

[drc]

The 1880s Sporting Times rarely come up for sale. I assume because they're rare.

A lot rarer than the Just So's

[redmansam]

Looking for a 1962 Kahn's Purkey with NO autograph.

[Matthew H]

Originally Posted by z28jd

He is another card that doesn't come up, along with about 50 other OJ players. Just like with the Cross, it will go for big bucks when it does show up just because we haven't seen one recently. Try finding a Taylor Shaffer, my good friend Kevin will tell you that you shouldn't let one of these tough players get away, even if it isn't the player you're looking for, you could always try to use it as trade bait. I would love to get a William Veach OJ but I've never even put it on my wantlist for a reason, I'm not going to be able to afford it if it does come up

John, what do you think a cross would go for? he is also on my want list

I think I wouldn't bid too crazy, though, I think Louiville cards have been hitting the moon much harder then they have in the past... They're leaving craters.

I would also like to know your take on what a veach, we're one to surface as a single in a lot, would sell for.

Matt

[ephus]

They come up every once in a while, but I have not found an E300 Plows Candy for my type card collection.

[z28jd]

Cross is going to go for a ton if it is his Louisville version because he is so tough(and a great player) and the team is highly collectible by some big spenders. If you can find his Philadelphia version and it isn't the Player's League card, it could be in a more manageable price range. For a (low)gradeable one it will still be around 1k but there are so many variables, such as two pose collectors needing the card. They could battle it out one time and sky is the limit. I would say the longer you go without seeing it, the higher the price goes so I could be way off on that estimate.

Veach, if it isn't his California League card(which could go 6 figures), would be another sky is the limit card. I think even if a pose collector has his pose, they are still bidding on it because they know it is great trade bait. Hard to put a price range on it. I know I'd give it a good effort but wouldn't expect to be among the top 2 bidders.

Collecting an OJ player set(even without Cal Lg cards) isn't for the faint of heart or an impatient person. There are enough common players in the set to keep you occupied for awhile though, plus different poses of easy players

Originally Posted by Matthew H

John, what do you think a cross would go for? he is also on my want list

I think I wouldn't bid too crazy, though, I think Louiville cards have been hitting the moon much harder then they have in the past... They're leaving craters.

I would also like to know your take on what a veach, we're one to surface as a single in a lot, would sell for.

Matt

[Matthew H]

Thanks for your input John. I believe there were two crosses in the Oregon find.

[Bicem]

Monarch Bender postcard (or Collins or Plank)

[z28jd]

Originally Posted by Matthew H

Thanks for your input John. I believe there were two crosses in the Oregon find.

Just checked, didn't see any in the Oregon Find, saw one in the Indy find and that one was sold before I knew about it. If you have any other questions, just PM me. If there is one thing I know, it is how much OJ's usually cost(usually more than I can afford) and which ones are harder to find. You learn a lot about them by being an underbidder more often than not

[Matthew H]

Nice, thanks John, I'll be blowing up your inbox at some point.

-Matt

[williamcohon]

Zeenut Cohen, Zeenut Danning.

[JLange]

"...that one's not for sale!"

[paul]

Zeenut Coveleski

[e107collector]

Every card on my wanlist!

Tony

[Dave1943]

A T206 SC Factory 25 and Cycle of my Grandfather - Doc Adkins.

Respectfully,

Dave

[Wite3]

t204 bransfield in a condition I can afford

[Exhibitman]

1925-31PC Back Exhibit Baseball:
Faber(silhouette bg)
Todt(silhouette bg)

1968 Atlantic Oil
AL 3 Freehan
AL 4 Davis
AL 7 McCraw
AL 8 Etchebarren
NL 2 Agee
NL 5 Banks
NL 6 Fairly
NL 7 Swoboda match w/#8 win $5
NL 8 Williams
NL 11 Osteen

[kkkkandp]

Don't listen to John Dreker - he has a secret OJ agenda! And he will never let me live down my infamous Taylor Shafer blunder!

I can second John's assertion on the scarcity of the Lave Cross N172. I found an N173 of him before I ever obtained my N172. And I found both the Buster Hoover and Williamson and mascot to be particularly vexing. Like a long list of others, I would love to obtain a Jake Wells and a Peek-A-Boo Veach (because of their interesting backgrounds) as well as a Frank Hankinson. He's the last player I need for my New Jersey Old Judge subset.

T205 Matty AB, 205 Cycle Grant, 205 Cycle Dahlen, 205 Gibson AB. Just a few of my "White Whales" so to speak.

[Matthew H]

Originally Posted by kkkkandp

Don't listen to John Dreker - he has a secret OJ agenda! And he will never let me live down my infamous Taylor Shafer blunder!

I can second John's assertion on the scarcity of the Lave Cross N172. I found an N173 of him before I ever obtained my N172. And I found both the Buster Hoover and Williamson and mascot to be particularly vexing. Like a long list of others, I would love to obtain a Jake Wells and a Peek-A-Boo Veach (because of their interesting backgrounds) as well as a Frank Hankinson. He's the last player I need for my New Jersey Old Judge subset.

Kevin, if it makes you feel better, I don't know about your Taylor Schafer blunder and I promise not to try to find out

[philliesphan]

1913 Zeenut Harry Heilman(n) with coupon.

Heck, I've only seen three examples without coupons over the last five years...

[cdn_collector]

Originally Posted by Pup6913

T205 Matty AB, 205 Cycle Grant, 205 Cycle Dahlen, 205 Gibson AB. Just a few of my "White Whales" so to speak.

Andrew -- I agree about the AB Gibson. I saw one on eBay a number of months back and hesitated because I couldn't tell if it was real (admittedly I was skeptical because to that point I had never heard of one existing). Could be a while before that one is seen again.

Another Gibson that doesn't hit the block too often is the e92 Croft's Cocoa.

Regards,

Richard.

[z28jd]

Originally Posted by Matthew H

Kevin, if it makes you feel better, I don't know about your Taylor Schafer blunder and I promise not to try to find out

Matt, I'll tell you all about it when you write me...trust me, it is a good story

I'll also tell you about my own OJ blunder, not such a good story

[kkkkandp]

Originally Posted by z28jd

Matt, I'll tell you all about it when you write me...trust me, it is a good story

See, that's the difference between me and John...he'll hang out my dirty laundry in public, but I keep his skid-marked skivvies private. Ummm....well, you know what I mean!

[esd10]

ive been looking for a n172 tony mullane and cant seem to find one

[sycks22]

T206 Piedmont or sweet caporals

[z28jd]

Originally Posted by esd10

ive been looking for a n172 tony mullane and cant seem to find one

Mullane seemed fairly easy for a time. I haven't really been looking for his cards because I have two and at one time had a third but traded it away. I'm guessing people are holding on to him because he seems like a possible HOF player someday. After what the HOF election did to the price of Bid McPhee cards, that probably isn't a bad idea

[the-illini]

N172 Ned Williamson- formal wear. Lew Lipset had one in an auction about 10 years ago - I bid around 2k but I dont think I had a chance. I haven't seen one since. Also would like a McCormick in a top hat and suit since I am dreaming...

[dlfallen]

ANY card from:

1933 Wheaties Seattle Indians
1937 Imperial Candy Seattle Indians

[Robextend]

Rose Co. Waddell, also haven't seen a W555 Waddell in a while.

[Runscott]

I'm still waiting for two post-cards to appear at auction. Only one example of one, and I have never seen the second, though I feel certain it exists. There was a third I was looking for, also with only one example, but I acquired a second this year.

The English language is really a mess, isn't it?