Just So Cy Young Vs N172 Anson Uniform

[sycks22]

Which would you rather have and why?

[quinnsryche]

I vote Young. Anson was a racist and a Cub. Not sure which is worse.

[Matthew H]

Anson in uniform... (I'm not racist, I also don't hate Chicago)

[oldjudge]

Both great cards. Anson in Uniform is part of probably the most interesting set (IMHO) ever produced. The Young is part of a small regional set. For this reason I pick the Anson.

[sycks22]

I'm going to take a shot in the dark which card you were going to pick oldjudge

[autograf]

No brainer.....Anson....

[bn2cardz]

I chose the Young because the Anson uniform looks strange to me since it isn't even his body. Even before I found out that it was just his head on another's body it looked strange to me.

Also Young has ties to the St. Louis team.
And lastly I have yet to have Just So card in my collection.

[kkkkandp]

I am almost exclusively an Old Judge collector these days, so it would be the Anson without question.

[Leon]

Sort of funny how we lean toward what we collect. Young all the way for me....

[DeanH3]

Both awesome cards but I chose Young. It's hard to beat ol' Denton.

[Paul S]

Why is life so full of complicated decisions?

I picked the Anson because I don't have an Anson in my collection but I do have a couple of Young.

[gnaz01]

I chose Young because to me that image is iconic.

[HOF Auto Rookies]

Anyone have images?

[bcbgcbrcb]

My vote goes to Cy, it's a rookie card..........

[barrysloate]

I'm surprised the Young is winning so easily. I went with the Anson expecting it to be leading. A key card in a classic set seems more important than one in a more obscure set, but I guess other factors are being taken into account. Both are great cards, of course.

[TUM301]

Young, without a doubt for me. Besides the E 107 Matty would be my number one dream purchase. They don`t call it the Cy Young award for nothing.

[Exhibitman]

Needs one more category: Whichever one I can sell for more.