Just So Cy Young Vs N172 Anson Uniform
 

Which would you rather have and why?

I vote Young. Anson was a racist and a Cub. Not sure which is worse.:D

Anson in uniform... (I'm not racist, I also don't hate Chicago)

Both great cards. Anson in Uniform is part of probably the most interesting set (IMHO) ever produced. The Young is part of a small regional set. For this reason I pick the Anson.

I'm going to take a shot in the dark which card you were going to pick oldjudge;)

No brainer.....Anson....

I chose the Young because the Anson uniform looks strange to me since it isn't even his body. Even before I found out that it was just his head on another's body it looked strange to me.

Also Young has ties to the St. Louis team.
And lastly I have yet to have Just So card in my collection.

I am almost exclusively an Old Judge collector these days, so it would be the Anson without question.

Sort of funny how we lean toward what we collect. Young all the way for me....

Both awesome cards but I chose Young. It's hard to beat ol' Denton.

Why is life so full of complicated decisions?:confused:

I picked the Anson because I don't have an Anson in my collection but I do have a couple of Young.

I chose Young because to me that image is iconic.

Anyone have images?

My vote goes to Cy, it's a rookie card..........

I'm surprised the Young is winning so easily. I went with the Anson expecting it to be leading. A key card in a classic set seems more important than one in a more obscure set, but I guess other factors are being taken into account. Both are great cards, of course.

Young, without a doubt for me. Besides the E 107 Matty would be my number one dream purchase. They don`t call it the Cy Young award for nothing.

Needs one more category: Whichever one I can sell for more.