Quote:
Originally Posted by packs
If you say so. I can think of a million pitchers with 4 good seasons. Even Chesbro's Wikipedia includes notes about how dubious his selection was and Bill James himself says he's only in for his 1904 season.
|
As I just said above, he only had 4 excellent seasons and I think he is among the worst in the Hall of Fame. I agree with this. I would not vote for Chesbro either.
The claim that he only had 1 hall of fame level season and is in only for this season is pretty easily disproven by looking at his annual statistics.