Net54baseball.com Forums - Top Five Tough-to-Find Cards You Own

Net54baseball.com Forums (http://www.net54baseball.com/index.php)

- Net54baseball Vintage (WWII & Older) Baseball Cards & New Member Introductions (http://www.net54baseball.com/forumdisplay.php?f=2)

- - Top Five Tough-to-Find Cards You Own (http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=317262)

Top Five Tough-to-Find Cards You Own

I try not to remember too often the ones once held and beloved that no longer live with me and rejoice with the ones I still have. My top 5 are:

1. 1887 OJ Griffith RC
2. E98 Wagner - Orange Border
3. T227 Cobb
4. T205 Wallace - One Line of Stats.
5. Tie - '14 CJ Chance and Bresnahan no #.

The stories behind my acquisitions are great personal memories.

Gotta love life on the fringes...off the top of my head:

1920s uncatalogued strip card of Cobb

https://photos.imageevent.com/exhibi...Unc%20Cobb.jpg

1920s uncatalogued strip card of Simmons

https://photos.imageevent.com/exhibi...%20Simmons.jpg

1920 Universal Surprise Box Ruth-Johnson-Sisler-Coveleskie

https://photos.imageevent.com/exhibi...-Alexander.jpg

1949 Sommer & Kaufmann Lefty O'Doul, signed

https://photos.imageevent.com/exhibi...SK%20PDoul.jpg

1964 Penafiel (Mexico) Gehrig

https://photos.imageevent.com/exhibi...l%20Gehrig.jpg

I'll play.

Last PC796 I needed. Tough card.
https://photos.imageevent.com/kawika...96%20Plank.jpg

Red Belts would be a lot easier without the Palace of the Fans postcard.
https://photos.imageevent.com/kawika...ge/DMcD659.jpg

I reckon there's not too many T4s of ol' Buck out there.
https://photos.imageevent.com/kawika...k%20Weaver.jpg

Matty's brother is a tough Ullman.
https://photos.imageevent.com/kawika...0Mathewson.jpg

Henry's brother in all his glory.
https://photos.imageevent.com/kawika...J%20Matty1.jpg

My top five Hal Chase toughies:

-1919 T213-3 Coupon factory 8 overprint
-1906 W600
-1912 Baseball Bats
-Colgans Square Proof
-1910 T3 no offer back

Honorable mention, Piedmont Art Stamps, Orange Borders, T213 type 1s

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Only five?

S74-1 Silks - Cobb w/Red Sun back

S74-1 Silks - Cobb w/Helmar back

S74-1 Silks - Smith-Rustlers w/backing

S74 Silk Colored Proofs - Archer, Doyle, Kling, Phillipe (Only 5 silk proofs are known to exist, including 2 of Phillipe, making this the only know complete set of colored S74 silk proofs to exist.)

1921-30 Major League Die Cuts - Complete, unpunched Detroit team set sheet w/Cobb

Honorable mention:

E102 - Dots Miller w/big glove
1921 - Herpolsheimer's - John McGraw
Any Baseball Image - Magic Lantern Slide
BF2 - Ferguson Bakery Felt Pennant - Joe Jackson
1927 RinkyDink Stamps - Babe Ruth. (Both the large and small size stamps.)
1890 Old Judge - Player's League cards.

The Ganzel was my contribution to the Old Cardboard W600 gallery. The 2 Rose Co are really tough. Still looking for Niles for the trifecta. The 1906 Williams PC is rare and the E122 Bodie is pop 1 and may be a set rarity.

I think I sold all my rare
cards before the explosion that happened in the last 3 years. Lol. Joe

The 4 Colgans square proofs that I recently picked up are pretty hard to come by.

Card #5 is a non-sports card but pretty hard to find as well. Its the Rocket Freighter card from the 1954 Tip-Top bread set. For perspective, a PSA 2 of this card just sold on eBay for $511.

In no particular order:

Bill

Five "tough" cards....and, two extra tough "goodies"

David,
Your Obak Premium Weaver just leaves me in awh and speechless....beautiful, museum quality collectible!!!!
Thanks for sharing!
Tim

Ted, I love the pieces, but I am unclear about the reference to the 1904 "World Series" champions. Did you mean to post something else? The Buffalo team you posted were the Eastern League champions in 1904.

Quote:

Originally Posted by molenick (Post 2209761)

Michael

As I stated...."MLB W.S. was not played in 1904."

The NY Giants refused to play the MLB World Series vs. Boston Americans.
There is an excellent, well-written book on this subject titled...."THE YEAR THEY CALLED OFF THE WORLD SERIES", BY Benton Stark. I highly recommend it.

The "Junior" World Series ** between the Triple-A Minor League teams Buffalo Bisons (Eastern League) and St. Paul Saints (American Association) was won by Buffalo.

** Note....the Sports media of that era referred this post season event as the Junior W.S.

TED Z

T206 Reference
.

Got it....I knew the World Series wasn't played in 1904, but I didn't realize there was a Junior World Series played and that Buffalo won. Thanks for the clarification. I just didn't make the connection between Buffalo and the unplayed 1904 W.S.

Some of my faves, a bit over 5...

Erick

Fantastic cards and a great collection you have.

I love all those cards

Four more T206 cards and an E90-1 Wagner.

Ted as always, love that 1952 bowman uncut sheet!

Quote:

Originally Posted by ksfarmboy (Post 2210138)

Ted as always, love that 1952 bowman uncut sheet!

Clint

I love to show-it-off.

It's such a beautiful piece of artwork.

My scan of it is a little off. It is actually more vivid than my posting indicates.

TED Z

T206 Reference
.

Here are some of mine

I'm embarrassed to post after some of the crazy rare stuff shown here, but here are a few:

To me, the term "Tough-to-Find Cards" immediately suggests 1-of-1 cards. Here are 5 of the 1-of-1 cards (as per the pop reports) in the master collection of Sam Rice's cards that I am pursuing. Because the fronts of these cards all have the same pic of Sam, to keep you all from getting bored, I have included pics of the more-interesting backs. Can anyone kindly help me locate any of the Sam Rice cards I need that are listed in my signature line below?

some great cards so far. my contributions- the Dessau and Lowdermilk are 1/1's as far as I know.

That Lowdermilk just takes one's breath away.

1951 Bowman Uncut Sheet

This is in my top five- It was found in a wall with many others in Philadelphia- Printers scrap but no creases.

Jeff wow those are beautiful!

This N173 Ewing is unique. This pose is not known on an N172:

This is the unique Deacon White proof that led to the McGreachery N172.

All these particular card examples are tough to own, because I own them and they are not for sale.

And if they were to make it to other collections, their new owners might not know what to make of them. And might be tempted to throw them out. So, in a sense, making them tough for some to own.

Brian

1863 Harry and Sam Wright grand match ticket:

1871 Harry Wright Mort Rogers scorecard:

Great cards Jay. Hard to get much tougher than unique.

My tough to find cards aren't on the level of most of these other posts show. But here are mine.

.

Jay those are all fantastic!

Thanks guys, I hadn't seen the images in a while so it was fun to pull them out for this thread.

Here are a few of my tough ones

Jeff great Cobb postcard. Would love to see what that medal he’s wearing looks like in color and close up.

Quote:

Originally Posted by 25801wv (Post 2211412)

My only one.

That's a nice "only one" to have Eugene.

.

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldjudge (Post 2211340)

1871 Harry Wright Mort Rogers scorecard:

Wow!!!

All tough within the set, or from an impossible set...

Here are a few of mine. I'm glad I acquired some of the exhibit cards before they really got expensive.

As far as I am aware, I'm the only one who owns any of these cards (with the caveat that I haven't paid for the Hornsby yet but should be invoiced today).

1. Garrety Dry Cleaners John Morrison
2. Souby cabinets Farmer Vaughn
3. Robinson Cruso Bill Killefer
4. Hendlers Ice Cream Hugh Jennings
5. Cafe du Monde Whitey Glazner

+ Leader Novelty Rogers Hornsby

Very nice cards Glenn.

Great looking Hornsby card

Quote:

Originally Posted by darwinbulldog (Post 2211806)

Glenn,

Loving the W572 Garrety back. Nice one man.

.