Good Value for a 1933 Goudey Ruth #149 or #181?
 

Hi all, I need an expert opinion. I already have a 1933 Goudey Ruth #53.
Looking to add a second to my collection.

I'm torn between the red back #149, which I can get for $3k or
the #181 which I can get for $2900

See attached for pics of both of them. Wondering what everyone thinks is a better value and a smarter buy.
I have not had much luck lately finding either of these varieties for under $3k for grade of 1 or A or even (MC).

Thanks in advance!

Both in approximately the same rough shape. Red background is definitely more visually appealing to me.

Not clear on the "going rate" for them, but
 

The Red #149 is 1000% "better" than the other one.

Appreciate the feedback!

From a value perspective, do you think they both are a decent value? I'm ok with a lower grade card because I'll never be able to afford the 3's or the 4's. Just feeling it out if this is a fair price. Thanks

#149 looks familiar :)

Derek: if you look at eBay sold prices, you can get a decent view of the market price, assuming there are comparable sales. And with Goudey Ruth’s, that is most often the case.

3k or so sounds about right for a 1 in that shape. That red looks a lot better to me. Not even close.