1912 Pittsburg Pirates Hot Springs RPPC, 5 HOFers, help with IDs please

[T206Jim]

This is a 1912 RPPC of the Pittsburg Pirates in Hot Springs, Arkansas for Spring Training. Five HOFers are depicted: Wagner, Clarke, Carey, McKechnie and Dreyfus.

1912-Pirates-RPPC-Net54-large.jpg

1912-Pirates-RPPC-Net54-player-crop.jpg

Here are possible IDs I found on on the web. Can anyone confirm any other players?

Top, L-R: unidentified, unidentified, Ed Mensor? (OF), unidentified, unidentified, unidentified, Bill McKechnie (IF), unidentified, unidentified, unidentified, unidentified, unidentified, Hank Robinson? (P), George Gibson (C), unidentified, unidentified.

Middle L-R: Tommy Leach (3B), Max Carey (LF), Alex McCarthy (2B), Bobby Byrne (3B), Babe Adams (P), Fred Clarke (Mgr.), Barney Dreyfuss (Owner), Sam Watters (Vice President/Treasurer), Honus Wagner (SS), Marty O'Toole (P), Claude Hendrix (P), Mike Simon (C).

Front, L-R: Chief Wilson (CF), Dots Miller (1B), Wally Rehg (OF), Ham Hyatt? (OF), Mike Donlin (RF), Jack Ferry (P), Jimmy Viox (IF), Solly Hofman (OF), unidentified, King Cole (P), unidentified.

[bobbvc]

Top row 4th from left may be Ovid Nicholson who played in 6 games for the Pirates that year. Top row last on right looks a lot like Butts Wagner who wasn't on the team but probably got a jacket due to family connections.

[T206Jim]

Good eye! I can see in newspaper accounts that Al "Butts" Wagner was in the Hot Springs camp in 1912.

[bobbvc]

Almost certain that's Butts. Nicholson I'm 60-40 on.

[MartyFromCANADA]

33 players invited to camp in 1912. (Pitt.Press.Mar.1912)
Good Luck

The_Pittsburgh_Press_Sun__Mar_17__1912_.jpg