What are the rarest backs (not just T206 or T Cards)

[darwinbulldog]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

as per op's request...5 or so rarest pre WWI cards...no stamps...as stated...red crofts, T216 VE stand out as likely the rarest...Culligans are pretty tough.

Then I'd guess Pirate/Tango Eggs are relatively comparable...from a #'s perspective...although definitely not perception or demand or price.

Those are incorrect. These are my estimates of the populations of those issues.

Red Croft's: 14
T216 VE: 80
Pirates: 105
Tango Eggs: 400

[A2000]

Since we're talking about non T206 rare backs

[tedzan]

I'll throw these in for this discussion......


T208 Philadelphia A's Fireside


.

.


TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by darwinbulldog

Those are incorrect. These are my estimates of the populations of those issues.

Red Croft's: 14
T216 VE: 80
Pirates: 105
Tango Eggs: 400

96 Pirates cards were sold at once. You think there are only another 9 in the hobby?

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by Leon

96 Pirates cards were sold at once. You think there are only another 9 in the hobby?

Thats perhaps a different thread, but a question I am most interested in -- aside from the 96, how many other T215 Pirates are there? My chance was sold with 4 others a while back, and I know of an ungraded Pelty and an ungraded Meyers (split picture on front). I believe Sean C has one, but i dont know if its one of the 5 sold in 2013.

Ted, do you have a running list of T215 Pirates? Maybe we can start one?

[oldjudge]

M101-4 Mall Theatre

[tedzan]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Thats perhaps a different thread, but a question I am most interested in -- aside from the 96, how many other T215 Pirates are there? My chance was sold with 4 others a while back, and I know of an ungraded Pelty and an ungraded Meyers (split picture on front). I believe Sean C has one, but i dont know if its one of the 5 sold in 2013.

Ted, do you have a running list of T215 Pirates? Maybe we can start one?

Ryan

I have posted two threads on the "Pirate" cards.

Check-out this thread...... Comparison of checklists for T215-1 RED CROSS set vs "PIRATE" set

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...T215+red+cross


TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[Rhotchkiss]

Thank you sir!!

[edjs]

I think this is a pretty rare back.

[edjs]

And these backs are rare, though the card itself is more interesting than the back (not mine, I just lifted the image from HA).

[Sean]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Thats perhaps a different thread, but a question I am most interested in -- aside from the 96, how many other T215 Pirates are there? My chance was sold with 4 others a while back, and I know of an ungraded Pelty and an ungraded Meyers (split picture on front). I believe Sean C has one, but i dont know if its one of the 5 sold in 2013.

Ted, do you have a running list of T215 Pirates? Maybe we can start one?

Yes, my Pirate back is one of the group of five that were sold by REA in 2013. I checked at the time, and as I recall there were a total of 13 Pirate backs graded by PSA and SGC combined, not counting the set of 96. If you know of two ungraded cards, that totals 111 Pirates.

[tedzan]

Hey Ryan

Here's the link to my 1st thread regarding the "PIRATE" set...... http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...08#post1057208


TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[Rhotchkiss]

Thanks Ted. And if Pete's list is reasonably correct, seems the t206 Browm OM, ty Cobb back, brown Lenox and the 213-3 overprint should be before the t216s?

[gabrinus]

E104-3s with Nadja backs are rare......had these once.....Jerry

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Thanks Ted. And if Pete's list is reasonably correct, seems the t206 Browm OM, ty Cobb back, brown Lenox and the 213-3 overprint should be before the t216s?

if you're including t206...yes I agree...and as jerry says...e104-3's are very low in pop.

[darwinbulldog]

Originally Posted by Leon

96 Pirates cards were sold at once. You think there are only another 9 in the hobby?

That's my guess, yes. Perhaps I'm way off, but I think that's pretty close. I'm betting that there won't be another "find" of course.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by darwinbulldog

Those are incorrect. These are my estimates of the populations of those issues.

Red Croft's: 14
T216 VE: 80
Pirates: 105
Tango Eggs: 400

Oops!!! I spoke too quickly...so crofts candy reds definitely DO stand out as tougher than just about any other back of that type. Then we're getting to pops close to 100 at minimum it seems. Yes there was that sale of 96 pirates...i'd guess the pop to be somewhere around 200 or so.(likely less)

I suppose if we are talking toughest backs of tcard sized cards...pre wwI mainly, then these issues need to be in the mix.

e92 crofts candy red
t216 VE
T215 Pirate
T215 Red Cross both types
T213 Type I
t214 victory
Clement Bros
t208
ty cobb/cobb back because its not a t206.

what have I missed?

[philliesphan]

I'm surprised no one has mentioned the D355 Niagara Baking back.

I owned the Otto Knabe, which I subsequently traded to Dan Gannt, who sold it in his divestiture over the past ±2 years. I don't think I've ever seen any other D355 example in the last fifteen years.

The E104-III Nadja's are certainly rare - but I'm not sure if they're that much rarer than E104-III blank backs. Which, if that's the case, I'm not sure becomes a valid comparison. (I've owned seven or eight E104-IIIs, and have had a fairly even mix between blank and Nadja back)

A bit like OP, I am the proud owner of a Pirate and Brown Lenox back - two cards that are unlikely to leave my collection anytime soon.

m

[brass_rat]

D303 Mothers' Bread cards qualify as rare. Most known players only have 1 to 3 examples. There are 21 verified players, 52 graded cards (PSA+SGC), and strangely, 11 of those graded cards are Eddie Plank.

It's been said before, but worth repeating, that D303 General Baking and D303 Mothers' Bread should not have the same catalog number as there are players in each set that are not in the other.

[gabrinus]

Nice Steve....still can't believe that Matty got a 1 grade......Jerry

[brass_rat]

It's the most beautiful PSA 1 I've ever seen.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by brass_rat

D303 Mothers' Bread cards qualify as rare. Most known players only have 1 to 3 examples. There are 21 verified players, 52 graded cards (PSA+SGC), and strangely, 11 of those graded cards are Eddie Plank.

It's been said before, but worth repeating, that D303 General Baking and D303 Mothers' Bread should not have the same catalog number as there are players in each set that are not in the other.

D303 Mothers Breads are underrated. I think they are the definition of too scarce for their own good.

[Steve D]

If you want to include N-cards, N167 is undoubtedly the rarest back among them.

Steve

[tedzan]

I'm not sure exactly where in the hierarchy of things the Mello-Mint back ranks, but I've always considered it a cool-looking advertisement.
But, judging by the high value of these cards, these gems are pretty darn scarce.

TED Z

T206 Reference
.

[Sean]

Originally Posted by philliesphan

I'm surprised no one has mentioned the D355 Niagara Baking back.

I owned the Otto Knabe, which I subsequently traded to Dan Gannt, who sold it in his divestiture over the past ±2 years. I don't think I've ever seen any other D355 example in the last fifteen years.

The E104-III Nadja's are certainly rare - but I'm not sure if they're that much rarer than E104-III blank backs. Which, if that's the case, I'm not sure becomes a valid comparison. (I've owned seven or eight E104-IIIs, and have had a fairly even mix between blank and Nadja back)

A bit like OP, I am the proud owner of a Pirate and Brown Lenox back - two cards that are unlikely to leave my collection anytime soon.

m

Marc, who is on the Pirate? Is it Meyers?

[gabrinus]

Well, these probably aren't as rare as a Niagara Baking bu these are pretty rare......here's one........Jerry

[philliesphan]

Originally Posted by Sean

Marc, who is on the Pirate? Is it Meyers?

It's Doolan Fielding (need to stay aligned with my Phillies Phan moniker)

[HasselhoffsCheeseburger]

W502 "Home Run" back -- I've only seen one.

I've only seen three "Three Bagger" backs, for that matter.

[HasselhoffsCheeseburger]

Here's a "Three Bagger"