Any interest in an SGC piggyback submission? CLOSED!! Grades popped!!

[Lucas00]

Originally Posted by JollyElm

I rightfully have grievances about the top pair here, and I don't know what's going on with the 1968 Mantle.



• The Winfield rookie is a wrong back card, so after talking with them about it, here was the reply:

"The Winfield would be labeled as wrong back and get an A."



But they graded it a 6.5, even though they told me directly it would only get an 'authentic,' as I wanted it to. WTF??



• The Brett rookie is just a cool, wildly miscut card that I was under the impression would also only get the 'authentic' grade. The card itself is pretty sweet, but they number-graded it an SGC 1, presumably because of how miscut it is. Argh!!! What's the point of that? Everyone can see it's crazy cut, so I wanted nothing more than an 'A.' Were I ever to sell it, how would I explain it? All anyone is going to see is an SGC 1 grade PLUS it's terribly cut, making it fall into the negative number grade category for anyone looking at it. Geez.



• And the 1968 Mantle got an 'A?' grade. What in high heck is that? Questionable authenticity?? Do they think it's a fake? Hopefully, the slab will have an explanatory word present.



Attachment 543751

Sounds like the mantle and winfield grades got swapped.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Lucas00

Sounds like the mantle and winfield grades got swapped.

No. The Mantle is Authentic with a description of miscut. The winfield is not miscut. Some errors were made. And they don't really have a good customer service number.

[Lucas00]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

No. The Mantle is Authentic with a description of miscut. The winfield is not miscut. Some errors were made. And they don't really have a good customer service number.

That’s my kinda miscut...

[big-six]

There are two duplicates- 1953 Berra and Rizzuto.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by big-six

There are two duplicates- 1953 Berra and Rizzuto.

There were supposed to be duplicates. Let's let the cards come back and see what actually is in hand.

[bobbyw8469]

The problem was never with duplicates. The problem was I was asking if more than one person sent in the exact same card. I could never get a clear cut answer from anyone whether they did or not.