1967 Topps Stand-ups Question

[tyweb1]

I am new to the boards and was just wondering if PSA actually grades 67 Stand-ups that are not perforated. I received this back from them today in the mail with an authentic grade. Thanks in advance for your help. Nathan

[hcv123]

PSA is really sketchy on these. I had a die cut one graded at the national last year that they put in an "A" holder also - they had to be pushed a bit to even grade it?? The non die cut ones are truly "proofs" and as such per PSA standards would not get a numeric grade. Hope that helps.

-Howard

[tyweb1]

Originally Posted by hcv123

PSA is really sketchy on these. I had a die cut one graded at the national last year that they put in an "A" holder also - they had to be pushed a bit to even grade it?? The non die cut ones are truly "proofs" and as such per PSA standards would not get a numeric grade. Hope that helps.

-Howard

Thank you for the information Howard. I am still wondering as to why they graded a Fregosi and a McCarver without perforations, at least according to the population report, with actual grades. Possibly they are mislabeled.

Nathan

[ALR-bishop]

I have 20 of the 24, about half perforated and half proof, but none graded. We have two guys who post here, Bob and Larry, who have full sets which may all be perforated, and are a great source of info on these sets. I will let them know about this inquiry

[sflayank]

the first couple of standup proofs as well as discs they graded numerically...theyve since only graded them as authentic
i do not believe psa grades the thick standups..they dont have a holder for it

[tyweb1]

Originally Posted by ALR

I have 20 of the 24, about half perforated and half proof, but none graded. We have two guys who post here, Bob and Larry, who have full sets which may all be perforated, and are a great source of info on these sets. I will let them know about this inquiry

Thanks for the help.