Ebay Authentication - It Gets Personal

[Yoda]

I just reread Greg's email. All he states is 'that the card has been rejected by the Ebay protection program". By who? Why? What now? I suspect you guys are right and Greg overgraded the card and it was then deemed unworthy of nrmt, by I suppose PSA.
All I know is that I am sitting here fuming, out $537 and no Spahny to comfort me.. A pox on the Ebay protection program.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by Yoda

I just reread Greg's email. All he states is 'that the card has been rejected by the Ebay protection program". By who? Why? What now? I suspect you guys are right and Greg overgraded the card and it was then deemed unworthy of nrmt, by I suppose PSA.
All I know is that I am sitting here fuming, out $537 and no Spahny to comfort me.. A pox on the Ebay protection program.

Once again, it was NOT PSA, it was CSG.

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by Yoda

I just reread Greg's email. All he states is 'that the card has been rejected by the Ebay protection program". By who? Why? What now? I suspect you guys are right and Greg overgraded the card and it was then deemed unworthy of nrmt, by I suppose PSA.
All I know is that I am sitting here fuming, out $537 and no Spahny to comfort me.. A pox on the Ebay protection program.

Pretty sure you'll get a refund for the purchase.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by jayshum

Pretty sure you'll get a refund for the purchase.

I think it's automatic.

[robertsmithnocure]

Originally Posted by Yoda

I just reread Greg's email. All he states is 'that the card has been rejected by the Ebay protection program". By who? Why? What now? I suspect you guys are right and Greg overgraded the card and it was then deemed unworthy of nrmt, by I suppose PSA.
All I know is that I am sitting here fuming, out $537 and no Spahny to comfort me.. A pox on the Ebay protection program.

Yoda — this situation sucks, but you will GM will definitely make you 100% whole. There is not way that you will be out your $537 for more than a couple of days. As someone else mentioned, you could probably call or email GM directly and buy the card directly from him, outside of ebay.

[Lorewalker]

Originally Posted by Yoda

I just reread Greg's email. All he states is 'that the card has been rejected by the Ebay protection program". By who? Why? What now? I suspect you guys are right and Greg overgraded the card and it was then deemed unworthy of nrmt, by I suppose PSA.
All I know is that I am sitting here fuming, out $537 and no Spahny to comfort me.. A pox on the Ebay protection program.

As has been stated, CSG looks at raw cards sold on eBay valued over $250. PSA looks at graded cards sold on ebay valued over $250. If a raw card does not meet the seller's grade description it is rejected by CSG and the buyer is refunded by eBay. PSA was not involved in this. Also doubt that Greg, himself, was emailing you but someone who handles these things at Greg's.

[Gorditadogg]

Originally Posted by Yoda

I just reread Greg's email. All he states is 'that the card has been rejected by the Ebay protection program". By who? Why? What now? I suspect you guys are right and Greg overgraded the card and it was then deemed unworthy of nrmt, by I suppose PSA.

All I know is that I am sitting here fuming, out $537 and no Spahny to comfort me.. A pox on the Ebay protection program.

You said before GMC said the card was not authentic. Now you re-read it and it doesn't say that? There is a big difference between authenticity and grade, those are very different things. Can you copy the letter to your post please so we all can see what it says.

Sent from my SM-S906U using Tapatalk

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by Gorditadogg

You said before GMC said the card was not authentic. Now you re-read it and it doesn't say that? There is a big difference between authenticity and grade, those are very different things. Can you copy the letter to your post please so we all can see what it says.

Sent from my SM-S906U using Tapatalk

I think the confusion comes from the fact that eBay calls it the 'eBay Authentication' program, and when a card fails, eBay sends you an email that says the card "failed authentication". But it can fail for multiple reasons. One of which is the card's condition simply not matching the listing, or hidden flaws that are not visible in the images and not disclosed in the listing.