Oversized SGC Slabs

[JackR]

Has anyone else noticed SGC’s new slabs for oversized cards (7 1/2” x 10 1/2”) can’t be stacked one on top of another without using rubber bands?

I asked SGC why the oversized slabs weren’t designed the same way as the standard slabs, and they said it seems the oversized slabs weren’t meant to be stacked. They also said they’ve had very few complaints about them and don’t plan to change them.

I’m curious whether collectors of Turkey Reds, 1912 Silks, Kashin Premiums, 1936 R-312s and other oversized cards agree with SGC that this isn’t a problem?

(Note: I’m using the term “problem” loosely).

[ullmandds]

that's sure a lot of extra plastic!

[x2drich2000]

I'm more concerned with whether they crack open when you breathe on them like the old ones did. The old seemed more fragile than the cards themselves.

[chadeast]

I very much dislike them, despite being an SGC fan for regular sized cards. I cracked out [checks notes] 18 T3's from these holders during my T3 set journey, including a few pricey cards such as Walsh and Collins 3.5's and a Lajoie 4. Their large size is really hard to manage vs. the more compact PSA, the stacking issue is also annoying, and, somewhat disturbingly, they crack open with very little effort. They are a bad product, I easily prefer T3's in top loaders to these things.

[the-illini]

They don't stack, but it is a minor problem compared to the other issues with their holders for big cards. As others have said, I would avoid using SGC for oversized cards in general. I used to have a lot of M101-6 cards in SGC holders and the cards slip out of the gaskets very easily, the holders feel like they are made of cheap plastic and you can crack them open with your fingernails.

That is a great DiMaggio!

[nwobhm]

Those have been circulating on ebay…..SGC can keep them. They look terrible and are a storage nightmare. What jackass came up with those?

[Jay Wolt]

Doesn't the Topps Super fit in a postcard sized slab?

[bobbyw8469]

Horrible, horrible design. It is like they just picked the biggest one to accommodate most oversized cards and just alter the gasket accordingly.

[BobbyStrawberry]

And I thought their postcard slabs were awkward!

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by Jay Wolt

Doesn't the Topps Super fit in a postcard sized slab?

Yes, so do Kashins.

[YazFenway08]

holy shit those are terrible. did they just start using that size?? i have a couple of T3s and some other oversized cards in the newer tuxedo style and they look pretty cool and frankly don’t feel “cheap” in hand to me. is this something they started in the last couple of months?

[ejharrington]

Too big.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by ejharrington

Too big.

Exactly. That label is a country mile away from the card.

[Bigdaddy]

Originally Posted by nwobhm

Those have been circulating on ebay…..SGC can keep them. They look terrible and are a storage nightmare. What jackass came up with those?

Looks like something mocked up in a high middle school shop class.

Horrible.

[3-2-count]

Look at the bright side. If you decided to hang these on a wall think of the money you’ll be saving.

You’ll already have both the matte and picture frame covered.

[todeen]

I'm in agreement. I needed to send 3+ oversized cards to SGC but now I won't. How awful! I thankful you posted this so I didn't waste my money.

Sent from my SM-G9900 using Tapatalk