Yankees Ticket Dating Guide BOTCHED

[steve B]

On that most recent one, the NYC removed is described as being on the back.

[Shoeless Moe]

Originally Posted by steve B

On that most recent one, the NYC removed is described as being on the back.

Inconsequential.

These are blank back stubs.

These type stubs are not shown (should have been included, but not there, why, ask the Guide Master) on the Keyman Guide Site, they show Bleacher, Grandstand, & Stadium, but the info (The Printing Company) and premise should follow to any of the stubs.

These stubs had all the info on the front and the Guide saying the "NYC" was removed on the 1937 stubs (regardless of front or back) is just plain wrong as you can see from my screenshot of the 1937 one attached to a scrapbook paper with 1937 game info.

David argument of info being written wrong on stubs (which granted can happen and did from time to time) can NOT be disputed here. Nothing is written, it's the newspaper showing the date.

I have zero doubts the guide while correct on some years is also very wrong on some years, David knows this as well and has admitted such in this thread. Problem is there are so many tickets slabbed wrong by PSA, it's a giant mess, but rather then fix people just take whatever PSA puts on the label to be correct, and boy it is not in regards to undated Yankees stubs.

[Snapolit1]

It’s really cool that the one dude created this resource. I have used it. But if there are aspects of it that are wrong, shouldn’t anyone pointing out problems with it just be met with a huge thank you, I’ll look into it kind of response? And if you look into it and agree, change it. And if you ultimately don’t agree, have a dialog. Maybe you reach consensus, maybe you dont. Seems hard to believe this screaming match has gone on literally for years.

[ballparks]

Originally Posted by Shoeless Moe

Inconsequential.

These are blank back stubs.

These type stubs are not shown (should have been included, but not there, why, ask the Guide Master) on the Keyman Guide Site, they show Bleacher, Grandstand, & Stadium, but the info (The Printing Company) and premise should follow to any of the stubs.

These stubs had all the info on the front and the Guide saying the "NYC" was removed on the 1937 stubs (regardless of front or back) is just plain wrong as you can see from my screenshot of the 1937 one attached to a scrapbook paper with 1937 game info.

David argument of info being written wrong on stubs (which granted can happen and did from time to time) can NOT be disputed here. Nothing is written, it's the newspaper showing the date.

I have zero doubts the guide while correct on some years is also very wrong on some years, David knows this as well and has admitted such in this thread. Problem is there are so many tickets slabbed wrong by PSA, it's a giant mess, but rather then fix people just take whatever PSA puts on the label to be correct, and boy it is not in regards to undated Yankees stubs.

There are SO MANY tickets of many sorts that are slabbed incorrect by PSA. It's a complete schlimazel. Why anyone wants to slab a ticket and respected their assessment and grading of them is beyond me. It's a complete scam and the people who are doing this for them are not the experts by any stretch. It's a complete joke.

[Shoeless Moe]

Originally Posted by ballparks

There are SO MANY tickets of many sorts that are slabbed incorrect by PSA. It's a complete schlimazel. Why anyone wants to slab a ticket and respected their assessment and grading of them is beyond me. It's a complete scam and the people who are doing this for them are not the experts by any stretch. It's a complete joke.

You ain't kidding!

Here is one that was at Mile High Auctions:

https://www.milehighcardco.com/1934_...-LOT64125.aspx

Ticket clearly July "15"

Well a simple check of baseball reference or a Google search shows he suffered that Lumbago Attack and batted leadoff then left game on July "14"

https://www.baseball-reference.com/b...93407140.shtml


https://sabr.org/gamesproj/game/july...ainst-yankees/

July 15 game he has 4 at bats:
https://www.baseball-reference.com/b...93407150.shtml


How does PSA botch that???

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by Shoeless Moe

How does PSA botch that???

Because they are f'ing stupid OR they don't care OR both.

Doug "it takes one to know one" Goodman

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

Because they are f'ing stupid OR they don't care OR both.

Doug "it takes one to know one" Goodman

That is more than a little scary

So much for checks and balances

Or checking your work

[ballparks]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

Because they are f'ing stupid OR they don't care OR both.

Doug "it takes one to know one" Goodman

Both, plus you forgot GREEDY and LAZY.