1927 W560 Jimmie Foxx (raw) - PSA or SGC?

[Pubcubbie]

Just picked up this raw 1927 W560 Foxx and want to get it graded for my PC. The card does have some paper loss on the top, but the hand cut seems pretty good and borders are mostly good (minus the top/top corner). I've been trying to keep cards in numerical grade but assume this would grade out 'Authentic'.

1. If this was going into your collection, would you choose PSA or SGC? All of my other cards are PSA slabbed and I'm trying to keep consistency.
2. Any chance this may grade out at a 1? And if so, who is the better prospect for this, PSA or SGC?

Thanks!

[BobC]

1. If going into my collection, it would stay raw.

2. Authentic, given the hand cut and paper loss. I know TPGs change their grading standards over times, but not sure either of the mentioned TPGs are in that area right now where they would give this a numeric grade. But since you seem to prefer PSA anyway, I'd say go with them.

Personally I'd say it deserves a numeric grade, just not sure the TPGs will give it one.

[bcbgcbrcb]

No clear choice here, as previously mentioned, if all of your other cards are PSA, probably makes sense to stick with that.