willie mickey duke opinions

[toyman55]

any opinions please on whether this is real or fake.
thanks.

[toyman55]

can't anyone give me a opinion?

[ATP]

Is that the only scan you have of it? It's hard to see between the clarity of the photo and the thicker sharpie. I am going to say I "think" the mantle looks ok, and the snider probably too, the brush in the ink happens with his sometimes because of how he signed. I would assume if the snider and mantle are good that the Willie would be as well but his i cant tell. Probably should wait for others to chime in too though before making a decision. I think people are hesitant to answer because it's hard to see very clearly.

[mighty bombjack]

I like it and think it's real. The Mays looks like the few that I got IP circa 1990. The Mantle looks slightly off to me, but within the realm of authenticity from my amateur eye.

[mr2686]

I agree, Mays and Snider look good, but hard to tell with that picture on the Mantle. It's probably good, but something seems just slightly off...maybe the angle or the last part of Mantle but as was said, it's within the realm of authenticity.

[shelly]

I hate anything framed. I think thaT could be a photo of a legitmate piece. The problem is you cant see the pressure on the photo so it could just be a picture of a picture.

[travrosty]

jsa authenticates through frames so no worry, mate!

[joed25]

I think it's real.

[dapro]

If one of those are fake, would you even buy it?

[toyman55]

Originally Posted by dapro

If one of those are fake, would you even buy it?

The seller withdrew it from her ebay auction when I asked if she would accept a return if psa turned it down.