Mantle's Signatures Value

[Seven]

As many of us know The Mick was a pretty prolific signer in his day. He was a regular on the show circuit, yet his signatures still commanded a premium, mainly because of his significance in the history of American pop culture.

I've tracked everything from 8x10's to single signed bats and balls. Mantle's signature is still a good amount above guys like Mays, DiMaggio and Williams. Just to pose a question to you all, had Mantle lived longer, do you think his signed products would be less valuable as of today? Even if it was something arbitrary like ten more years.

I would have to think he would be less valuable, as he would've had more time on the show circuit. Thoughts?

[rand1com]

I doubt it would make a difference. He really had stopped doing many shows well before he died. There will always be more collectors of Mantle's autograph than there are authentic examples. Imagine how many forgeries are hiding out in collections who think they have the real thing. If those were not around, his autograph would command much more than it does.

[Duluth Eskimo]

Originally Posted by rand1com

I doubt it would make a difference. He really had stopped doing many shows well before he died. There will always be more collectors of Mantle's autograph than there are authentic examples. Imagine how many forgeries are hiding out in collections who think they have the real thing. If those were not around, his autograph would command much more than it does.

I agree with this. If not for all the forgeries, his auto would be much much more. The demand will always be there. Quality is declining as each year goes by. Also, I very much wanted to get a Mitchell and Ness jersey signed before he died, but missed my opportunity as he just stopped doing shows (and the price went way up). Was also doing Upper Deck authenticated signings.