What’s everyone’s favorite set? I’ll go first!

[The Detroit Collector]

Prewar- E90-1 American Caramel
Post War- 1951 Bowman

[Brian Van Horn]

I don't have a favorite set. That's what makes collecting great in one respect.

[BearBailey]

Prewar T3
Postwar 1957 topps

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by Brian Van Horn

I don't have a favorite set. That's what makes collecting great in one respect.

Brian, I would have sworn it is the W504 set.

[ValKehl]

My co-favorite sets are 1910 E222 A.W.H. Caramels (because I collect Va. League cards and love rare cards) & 1925 Holland Creameries (because I collect cards of all the players who were on the 1924 WS Champion Wash. Senators team).

[commishbob]

PreWar...T205 beautiful little pieces of art

Postwar...1959 Topps While I remember seeing '58s and holding some in my hands the '59 cards were the first I owned. I still get a wave of nostalgia flipping through them.

[Jason Carota]

N172 Old Judge

[jayshum]

Pre-war: hard to beat T3s

Post-war: 1965 Topps is my choice today

[Corporal Lance Boil]

T204. Ramly. It has been a curse and a blessing.

[raulus]

Not really a set collector, as I'm first and foremost a player collector.

But if I'm collecting a set, then it's probably going to be something that not many people collect, and that are hard to find. Lately, I've been working on a few. Hard to pick just one because they're all special in their own way. Try not to hate the fact that they're all postwar. Here's the list:

1953-1954 Briggs Meats
1960 Bazooka Complete Boxes
1962 Jell-O Complete Boxes
1971 Bazooka Numbered
1973 Topps Comics

[vintagerookies51]

If the 13-card Jackie Robinson Bond Bread rookie set counts, I'll go with that. Otherwise can't beat the iconic T206

[CardPadre]

If I could collect from only one set, would be the 1933 Sport Kings. So many sports, really great bios on back, a playing days Ruth, female athletes, Native American, native Hawaiian, a card with a dog. Notably missing any black athletes...but quite a diverse and beautiful set otherwise.

[puckpaul]

I will go with the N162 set, such a beautiful early set with amazing artwork. I dont really have a favorite but having to pick just one today it is that one. (For some reason cant load images right now)

[soxinseven]

Originally Posted by Casey2296

1911 E94 George Close Candy Co.
-

I'm with Phil, E94s are the best.

[Eggoman]

LOVE T205s & Turkey Reds, even though I only have ONE T3...T3 Cobb - resized.jpg

T205 Baker SGC 55 F.jpg

Non-Sport - Mars Attacks!

TO have been a 10-year-old and collected them in 1962 AND to have one of my Nun Teachers find them in MY desk...I SURELY would have been KILLED!

[Gorditadogg]

Originally Posted by Eggoman

LOVE T205s & Turkey Reds, even though I only have ONE T3...Attachment 613332



Attachment 613333



Non-Sport - Mars Attacks!



TO have been a 10-year-old and collected them in 1962 AND to have one of my Nun Teachers find them in MY desk...I SURELY would have been KILLED!

Mars Attacks cards are way before my time, but the Tim Burton movie based on the cards is one of the funniest films ever.

Sent from my SM-S906U using Tapatalk

[collectt205]

T205 see username.

[Brian Van Horn]

Originally Posted by valkehl

brian, i would have sworn it is the w504 set.

lol 😆🤣.

[Rhotchkiss]

T206 is the king of all sets.

But how on God’s green has nobody mention the 1914 Cracker Jack set, yet?!?!

[Fred]

Originally Posted by z28jd

N172 Old Judge set. I love it because of the amount of poses and the fact that someone of these players aren't pictured anywhere else. These cards are the only picture proof of them. It's also loaded with great players, extreme rarities and various ways to collect the set.

Imagine chasing the cards of two career minor league players 135 years later because they are the only two players in the huge set on those particular teams? They are two of my favorite cards from the set.

John, really, you want us to believe your favorite cards for the OJ set don't include some dude named Larry... BTW - Nice Nyce.


Asking for a favorite set is a tall order. My mind changes all the time. Today, I'm going with T200. Sixteen card set with all the major stars included (Wags, WaJo, Matty, Thorpe, Cobb, Lajoie, Joe Jackson and the rest).

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

T206 is the king of all sets.

But how on God’s green has nobody mention the 1914 Cracker Jack set, yet?!?!

Ryan, I suspect you missed seeing posts #18 & #27 in this thread. BTW, very nice Cracker Jacks!

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by ValKehl

Ryan, I suspect you missed seeing posts #18 & #27 in this thread. BTW, very nice Cracker Jacks!

Lol. I did miss those. I need pictures!

[EGreenwood]

Pre-war

N162 (I would drool every time Ted would post his set)

Post-war

1960-62 Bell Brand Dodgers

[kkkkandp]

Hands down, N172.

For me, the cards make 19th century baseball truly come alive because the images are real photos. They pair so well with books like David Nemec's The Great Encyclopedia of 19th Century Major League Baseball and The Beer and Whiskey League.

And there are the goofy poses!

Fred: Is this the Larry of whom you speak?

[Svabinsky78]

Too many....

Prewar.....T205, 1906 Fan Craze (technically a game), 33 and 34 Goudey

Postwar....50-52 Bowman and 52-56 Topps

[Hirbonzig]

R327 Diamond Stars
1967 Topps

[toledo_mudhen]

Prewar - T206

Post War - 1955 Topps is Loaded with Stars and Rookies plus 206 Cards is not insurmountable for this great classic ball card set.

[fisherboy7]

E107 Breisch-Williams by far for me.

N162 Goodwin champions a distant second.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[dfletch00]

pre-war E94
Post war 1956 / 1976 tie

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by Eggoman

LOVE T205s & Turkey Reds, even though I only have ONE T3...Attachment 613332

Attachment 613333

Non-Sport - Mars Attacks!

TO have been a 10-year-old and collected them in 1962 AND to have one of my Nun Teachers find them in MY desk...I SURELY would have been KILLED!

That's a great looking T3 Cobb. If you're only going to have one card from that set, you made a good choice.

[Eggoman]

THANKS, Jay!

ex-Orly Collection - and a card that I NEVER thought I'd own!

It's ONLY a PSA-1 for a couple of specks of paper loss on the reverse, but a BEAUTY, IMO anyway...

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by Eggoman

THANKS, Jay!

ex-Orly Collection - and a card that I NEVER thought I'd own!

It's ONLY a PSA-1 for a couple of specks of paper loss on the reverse, but a BEAUTY, IMO anyway...

Wow, I'll take any 1's that look like that any day.

[Leon]

Near the top of my list of favorites...

[yanks4]

Red rules!

[robw1959]

I'll have to go with 1933 Goudeys, but the T205 set is a pretty close runner-up, especially in high grade.

[MVSNYC]

Fun thread!

Ryan, your '14 CJ's are stunning.

.................................................

For me...there's only answer:

[Zach Wheat]

Originally Posted by philliesfan

Mine is the T3. I do not have any but a beautiful set. I will get one some day. Either Safe At Third or Out At Third.........one day.
Bob

For pre-war I have to agree with Bob that the T3's bring a particular allure. I don't collect T3's primarily due to size issues, but I like the set.

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by Zach Wheat

For pre-war I have to agree with Bob that the T3's bring a particular allure. I don't collect T3's primarily due to size issues, but I like the set.

Thanks Mike. Some nice cards back at ya!

T3 is a great set. What attracted me to it is that many action poses are the same in t06 (Cobb bat on, matty, wajo, etc). Most sets I collect are offshoots/have same poses as t206 poses - e107, w600, Rose Co PC, T3

[oldjudge]

For me, not surprisingly, it's Old Judges. It was the first major baseball card set and I believe the greatest set ever produced. It has almost 30 HOFers and an incredible array of scarce teams represented.

[steve B]

I rarely have a real favorite, and it can change day to day

A few sort of in order.

George C miller
41 Goudey
48 Leaf
T204
1950 Drakes
48 Bowman.

[Alaskanmade]

T205 for me.
Stats on back, portraits, vibrant colors, player signatures, it really has it all.

[jingram058]

Originally Posted by Alaskanmade

T205 for me.
Stats on back, portraits, vibrant colors, player signatures, it really has it all.

You nailed it, sir! Best pre-war set, hands down, IMO.

For post-war, it's a toss up for me, 1953 Bowman color and/or those wood-paneled, Halloween-backed 1962 Topps.

[oldphil]

T205s all the way.

[MMarvelli]

Zeenuts

You can't ever complete the complete set.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by MMarvelli

Zeenuts

You can't ever complete the complete set.

For the same reason my favorite is the m113 / m114 combined set.

[Baseball Rarities]

My favorites are the 1908 PC760 Rose Co. postcard and the 1902-11 W600 Sporting Life cabinet sets.

If I had to choose just one, I would probably go with the Rose Co. set. I love the black and white portraits (mostly taken by Horner) coupled with the green backgrounds, white baselines and figural players along with the ornate gold embossing.

With a total of 206 different subjects, most people do not recognize how large the 1908 set actually is. Each of the 16 Major League teams is represented by 12 players - usually 8 fielders and 4 pitchers. Plus, the Scranton Minor League team has another 14, including Moonlight Graham. There are 26 Hall of Famers including virtually all of the day's stars.

There are many levels of scarcity within the set. Some of the cards have only a single known example while some of the more popular players of the day have nearly 10.

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by Baseball Rarities

My favorites are the 1908 PC760 Rose Co. postcard and the 1902-11 W600 Sporting Life cabinet sets.

If I had to choose just one, I would probably go with the Rose Co. set. I love the black and white portraits (mostly taken by Horner) coupled with the green backgrounds, white baselines and figural players along with the ornate gold embossing.

With a total of 206 different subjects, most people do not recognize how large the 1908 set actually is. Each of the 16 Major League teams is represented by 12 players - usually 8 fielders and 4 pitchers. Plus, the Scranton Minor League team has another 14, including Moonlight Graham. There are 26 Hall of Famers including virtually all of the day's stars.

There are many levels of scarcity within the set. Some of the cards have only a single known example while some of the more popular players of the day have nearly 10.

Fantastic cards Kevin, thanks for posting.

[Bcwcardz]

1975 and 1976 Topps baseball.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[kkkkandp]

Originally Posted by Baseball Rarities

If I had to choose just one, I would probably go with the Rose Co. set.

Kevin,

Those are beautiful!

Kevin

[quinnsryche]

Pre-War: T3
Post-War: 1953 Bowman Color