PWCC's 1936 Goudey World Wide Gum DiMaggio PSA 7

[Stonepony]

Highly, highly sickening chain of events unfolding.

[jmb]

Originally Posted by Stonepony

Highly, highly sickening chain of events unfolding.

agreed.

[BeanTown]

So, this makes sense why Brent didn't come on this thread to chime in when myself along with others asked him to, plus John (The consignor to PWCC) said he would. I see PWCC does full disclosures on other cards which I guess PWCC "Brent" is not vested in. Plus, Orlando said it best earlier which I agreed on earlier posts that the submitter of the card had to have some pull to get that kind of inflated grade with PSA. Even the second go around which I highly doubt the card was sent back to PSA, to be reconfirmed of the grade.

I feel bad for Courtney who for one, probably didn't do all the research he should have when buying a 50k plus card but I do understand having trust from the auction house or private sale you want to take them at their word and assume they are disclosing everything.

[Leon]

Whether anything was disclosed or not how did it affect the Goldin Auction sale?
Did Courtney (hi Courtney) lose his money well before any alteration/cleaning was known? Wasn't it in an auction as a straight up 7 with 0 discussions of anything else?
IF that is the case did it have a material effect on that sale?... Damages?

Originally Posted by BeanTown

So, this makes sense why Brent didn't come on this thread to chime in when myself along with others asked him to, plus John (The consignor to PWCC) said he would. I see PWCC does full disclosures on other cards which I guess PWCC "Brent" is not vested in. Plus, Orlando said it best earlier which I agreed on earlier posts that the submitter of the card had to have some pull to get that kind of inflated grade with PSA. Even the second go around which I highly doubt the card was sent back to PSA, to be reconfirmed of the grade.

I feel bad for Courtney who for one, probably didn't do all the research he should have when buying a 50k plus card but I do understand having trust from the auction house or private sale you want to take them at their word and assume they are disclosing everything.

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by Leon

Whether anything was disclosed or not how did it affect the Goldin Auction sale?
Did Courtney (hi Courtney) lose his money well before any alteration/cleaning was known? Wasn't it in an auction as a straight up 7 with 0 discussions of anything else?
IF that is the case did it have a material effect on that sale?... Damages?

Someone would have to sell the card with all of that being disclosed to find out for sure.
Im sure it would still go for far above what it did in the SGC holder even with all of this knowledge. Plus rookie cards keep climbing, if its sold 4 years from now who knows..