Biggest MVP snubs ever

[G1911]

Originally Posted by packs

I compared two pitchers because they were both up for the Cy Young.

I don’t think you understand my opinions don’t need to pass your smell test. You aren’t the arbiter of anything, to use your phrasing.

But it is improper to compare 2 players up for the MVP using the same exact metric? Surely you can step back and see why that doesn’t make much sense.

Never claimed to be the arbiter. Your opinions do not need to pass my ‘smell test’. I am allowed to comment, just as you are and do. Try harder.

[cgjackson222]

Under 10 posts in and we are already bickering.

Really had high hopes that this would be a bicker-free thread, but alas.

[packs]

Originally Posted by G1911

But it is improper to compare 2 players up for the MVP using the same exact metric? Surely you can step back and see why that doesn’t make much sense.

Never claimed to be the arbiter. Your opinions do not need to pass my ‘smell test’. I am allowed to comment, just as you are and do. Try harder.

I was talking about the Cy Young. It’s an award that typically goes to the “best” pitcher. Statistically , Clemens wasn’t the best pitcher.

The V in MVP stands for value. It can’t be determined with one stat. I didn’t mention WAR in any context.

You’re the only one using WAR to determine who should win MVP.