Most valuable card

[SMPEP]

But wait ... I thought I had heard that all three PSA 10 Mantles had been hand cut from those uncut sheets.

Doesn't that make them "trimmed" too?

I mean the grade on them is just as bogus because they were not factory cut and issued cards.

Why the question marks and discrimination on the Wagner and not the Mantles? All 4 have been doctored in one way or the other.

Cheers,
Patrick

[Baseball Rarities]

Originally Posted by SMPEP

But wait ... I thought I had heard that all three PSA 10 Mantles had been hand cut from those uncut sheets.

What uncut sheets?

I assumed that all three Mantles are from Rosen's find.

[SMPEP]

Originally Posted by Baseball Rarities

What uncut sheets?

I assume that all three Mantles are from Rosen's find.

Perhaps I heard wrong ... but I was told all three came from when that guy brought in the group of uncut high number sheets at one of those early card shows (back in the 1970s? 1978? in Atlantic city?). I seem to recall even hearing that the three Mantles were cut from the sheet right in front of someone at PSA and then directly handed to them for grading. (If I'm wrong on this - someone please correct me!)

I thought I had pictures somewhere of that sheet ... but all I could readily find in my photo archive was one of the other uncut sheets that walked in the door that day.

Cheers,
Patrick

[MW1]

Originally Posted by SMPEP

But wait ... I thought I had heard that all three PSA 10 Mantles had been hand cut from those uncut sheets.

Do you have a source? Did a specific person tell you this?

I seem to recall even hearing that the three Mantles were cut from the sheet right in front of someone at PSA and then directly handed to them for grading.

So someone brought an uncut 1952 Topps high number sheet with Mantle on it to a convention in the late 1990s or 2000s (or later?) when PSA was grading onsite and cut the sheet up in front of them? I've never heard of this before. Are you sure? This doesn't seem possible or believable...especially considering that I know where the first PSA 10 Mantle came from.

[irv]

Originally Posted by MW1

Do you have a source? Did a specific person tell you this?


So someone brought an uncut 1952 Topps high number sheet with Mantle on it to a convention in the late 1990s or 2000s (or later?) when PSA was grading onsite and cut the sheet up in front of them? I've never heard of this before. Are you sure? This doesn't seem possible or believable...especially considering that I know where the first PSA 10 Mantle came from.

It doesn't mean the story isn't true, but I have never heard of that before either?

Hopefully the poster can dig up some more info on it.