Value on 50's willie mays game used bat

[bat_master]

Originally Posted by ooo-ribay

I somewhat agree with Matt, but not entirely. I would place the value a little higher although game useage is obviously a huge factor. Is there tar on the handle? IMO, Adirondacks are more desirable than LS because Willie had contract with Adirondack. Thus, you get his signature rather than a block MAYS. I own a 61-63 white letter Mays and keep my eyes open for auction results of comparables. If your bat has any kind of decent usage, I would value it higher than Matt. If it has no use, I really couldn't guess at a value.

I agree with Matt on this. The valuation I sent to Pete by PM was virtually identical. H&B bats are more valuable than Adirondacks and the auction results back it up. Also, Mays wasn't known for his use of pine tar until the late 1960s/early 70s.

Which Malta book is that you are talking about? BATS from 1995? Information has come a long way in the last 20 years. It is still a great book, but it's really just one of three books necessary for any true "bat guy's" library. I wish there were more.

[UnVme7]

Regardless of use, bat collectors love the white lettered Adirondacks. They look super sharp! But yes, his H&B bats will have more value.

[ooo-ribay]

Originally Posted by bat_master

I agree with Matt on this. The valuation I sent to Pete by PM was virtually identical. H&B bats are more valuable than Adirondacks and the auction results back it up. Also, Mays wasn't known for his use of pine tar until the late 1960s/early 70s.

Which Malta book is that you are talking about? BATS from 1995? Information has come a long way in the last 20 years. It is still a great book, but it's really just one of three books necessary for any true "bat guy's" library. I wish there were more.

I didn't realize HBs held a premium. Is it not true that Willie's main contract was with Adirondack?

Yes, the old Malta book. Which others would you recommend? I also have the Mastro Bushing/Knoll guide.

[perezfan]

I also believe the white letter Adirondacks carry a significant premium. They are arguably the most attractive bats of the era, and are quite tough to acquire.

Mays' contract was indeed with Adirondack, and not LS. As a collector, I would prefer the Adirondack to the block-letter Mays LS. Mays is a definite exception to the collecting "norm".

[ullmandds]

thanks for all the info guys. my friend is the original owner...he got it at a game while walking off the field after the game. as far as I know he has no interest in selling at this time. I will link him here if he wants to add anything thats up to him.