Comparing Boxers with Baseball Players

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

I was an avid baseball card collector before I sold my collection and turned my attention to boxing cards. For this reason, I tend to compare vintage heavyweight boxing with vintage baseball. I'm not sure if anyone else does this. Just thought I would share this concept with everyone to see your thoughts. The way it works is as follows:

BLANK is to Boxing as BLANK is to Baseball

Here is how I see it. There are no right or wrong answers.

John L. Sullivan - Cap Anson (first 2 true superstars in their respective sports)
Jim Corbett - Mike Kelly (overshadowed by Sullivan and Anson in collectors eyes)
Bob Fitzsimmons - Nap Lajoie (both under-rated)
Jim Jeffries - Honus Wagner (not including the T206)
Jack Johnson - Ty Cobb (keys to any turn of the century set - Cobb would roll over in his grave if he heard this comparison)
Jess Willard - Walter Johnson (both huge men from Kansas)
Jack Dempsey - Babe Ruth (2 most popular athletes of the 20's)
Gene Tunney - Lou Gehrig (overshadowed by Dempsey and Ruth in collectors eyes)
Joe Louis - Jackie Robinson (no explanation necessary)
Rocky Marciano - Joe DiMaggio (popular Italian Americans)
Muhammad Ali - Mickey Mantle (popularity among collectors)
Joe Frazier - Willie Mays (overshadowed by Ali and Mantle in collectors eyes)

That's enough for now. I think you get the picture. Am I the only one who wastes time thinking about this?

[Archive]

Posted By: D. Bergin

When I first got into collecting boxing it was because I liked older material and I couldn't really afford Babe Ruth and Ty Cobb cards and memorabilia and I wanted to collect an iconic athlete from the early 20th century or so.

Jack Johnson is the boxer I latched on to and it pretty much snowballed from there.

I can't say I've struggled with any of the same comparisons you have. Interesting concept though.

Who's Harry Greb in the baseball world? Died young, fought a ton of fights but not a lot of material on him and extremely popular among collectors.

[Archive]

Posted By: John Nguyen

Christy Mathewson - died young, top 5 pitcher of all time, top tier HOFer, original HOF class inductee.

[Archive]

Posted By: Andy Baran

Maybe Addie Joss?

[Archive]

Posted By: boxingcardman

Babe Ruth: Muhammad Ali. The greatest personalities of the 20th century in their respective sports.

Lou Gehrig: Gene Tunney. In the shadows of their predecessors.

Nolan Ryan: George Foreman. Who wants to play forever?

Mickey Mantle: Max Baer. Playboys who pissed away the chance to be the greatest of them all.

Pete Rose: Jake La Motta. Doomed by their own personalities.

Rafael Palmiero: Fernando Vargas. They both got caught.

Barry Bonds: Shane Moseley. Same script, different sports. In an interview with ESPN.com Moseley said: "Unknowingly, yes, some of the substances they are talking about, were being used as part of the workouts. I didn't know what the hell it was." Riiighhhttt....


Sic Gorgiamus Allos Subjectatos Nunc

[Archive]

Posted By: S Gross

Tommy Burns --- Eddie Collins -----> Somehow never mentioned when the subject of great baseball'ers/boxers are brought up.