T206 broad leaf 350 or red hindu? Which is tougher and more expensive?

[atx840]

BL350
Common enough that every month or so a few come up, currently there are 4 up for auction. A board member purchased a beater common example for $100, my PSA 2.5 (clean back) went for $500.

Red Hindu
I recently picked up an example and had three to choose from, it has been said that a 4/5 will be available in the next few months. A beater example (large hole, missing paper) went for $280 on the bay, an SGC 10 for $600 and a mid grade HOF $4500+.