Negro Leaguers in the HOF - Any More?

[triwak]

I would respectfully disagree with the "one last vote" opinion stated earlier. While I agree that eventually any group or era of players will be exhausted of HOF qualifiers, my question would be: Why not let that happen naturally? You just never know how future events might effect historical judgment. Best example of that, is how the current awareness of the steroid scandal has opened eyes on the true value of earlier players who, achieved less gaudy numbers, but did so cleanly. I think the best thing the Hall has done in recent years, with all the voting rule changes, has been to open up the eligibility of ALL players from the past, as long as they played the minimum 10 years (in the majors, Negro Leagues, or combined).

[bcbgcbrcb]

I agree with Ken on this one.

[novakjr]

In a way I agree with you Ken. The main point of emphasis in my statement was "the voters with the knowledge that it's now or never, should take their time and get that final vote right. Not that they will though." At it's core I like the thought of one last vote, BUT I agree that they will NOT get it right, and because of that fact, they probably shouldn't do it.

Also, as a collector, I like the idea of potential HOFers still floating around out there amongst the old timers. I think the speculation is good for the hobby, and new(old) hall of famers can often spark new interest in the pre-war/negro league market..

[triwak]

Yeah, I'm always kinda excited for the Veterans Committee elections. Sometimes a little nervous too! ($$$)

[aljurgela]

I think that most of the names on the list are solid and I would not have many to add. I think that it is clear that Buck O'Neil will get in for contributions to the game, not as a player, which I think is right. Wish it would have happened while he could enjoy it.

Anyway, the next question is how to handicap the possibilities of the players who are "on the edge". For instance, John Donaldson will have a much higher probability than Nip Winters, in my opinion. Dick Lundy will have a better shot than Dobie Moore.

Maybe an interesting analysis would be to try and measure who is outside of the HOF in a quantitative way... Courrier poll, E/W all star games, other opinions and see what show up. Sounds like a fun project for a raining day. I will take a look at this and maybe post something in a couple of weeks.

Does anyone know if the data from the Negro League Committee was released to SABR as rumored? I have not seen that data.

[novakjr]

Originally Posted by triwak

Yeah, I'm always kinda excited for the Veterans Committee elections. Sometimes a little nervous too! ($$$)

I always like the thought of cards of players who are treated as semi-stars or sometimes commons, suddenly bringing in low end Hall of Fame prices. I definitely enjoy seeing t206 players, hell any player, come up on the pre-43 ballot.