FWIW -- SGC x-over to PSA

[bobbyw8469]

When the SGC graded card comes back EOT from PSA, and then you send it back to SGC and then THEY say it is trimmed, what happens then?????

[Butter]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

When the SGC graded card comes back EOT from PSA, and then you send it back to SGC and then THEY say it is trimmed, what happens then?????

Well if it was a high dollar card I might think about suing them. They say they only guarantee the card while it's in the SGC holder, but that doesn't really hold much weight. You hopefully may also be a little more hesitant to crack open SGC holders in the future.

[grundle20]

Robby....then I mail them back their claim of it trimmed with their ORIGINAL slab that had it graded NQ (and why not cc PSA and Beckett on the letter) and ask them to "explain this one..." Heh...

[Butter]

Originally Posted by grundle20

Robby....then I mail them back their claim of it trimmed with their ORIGINAL slab that had it graded NQ (and why not cc PSA and Beckett on the letter) and ask them to "explain this one..." Heh...

I know of other people in this same situation. SGC said, "We only guarantee it when it is in the holder. If it is taken out of the holder, that guarantee is voided." You ought to just keep the case as I would think it would sell for a little more that out.

[pclpads]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

When the SGC graded card comes back EOT from PSA, and then you send it back to SGC and then THEY say it is trimmed, what happens then?????

If you are rich and an optimist, you keep playing submission roulette until you hit. Otherwise, you're screwed, have left a lot of coin on the table and are holding a card virtually worthless. This happened to me w/ a very desirable rc. I've learned since to buy the card you want in the holder you want and avoid playing the nonsensical, depressing XO game.