SGC has gone to far on these...

[Jay Wolt]

Originally Posted by bcbgcbrcb

Jay:

Assuming that you tried more than one month ago, why not try SGC now?

Phil, this was about 5 years ago.
Though about a year ago I had some Goodwin Champion Boxers that were skinned
and was told by SGC not even to bother to submit them as they would not be encapsulated.
So "Honest John" Morrill looks fine and protected nicely in the GAI slab,
will probably leave him be.

EDITED TO ADD: why would things be different in SGC's approach from the last month till now?

[Bicem]

If all BG's are cut from panels, should they not receive a numerical grade? What's the difference between them and the item that this thread was originally about?

[Matt]

A few years back SGC refused to slab a T206 with paper glued to the back as Authentic. I don't know if their policy has changed.

[bcbgcbrcb]

Jay:

Well, they never encapsuated tickets or photos before last month, why not give it a try? Maybe some things have changed with JSA in the picture now.

[novakjr]

BGS is apparently slabbing "Authentic" pages from the Spalding guides.
http://cgi.ebay.com/1920-Spalding-Ba...item4cf524b26a

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by novakjr

BGS is apparently slabbing "Authentic" pages from the Spalding guides.
http://cgi.ebay.com/1920-Spalding-Ba...item4cf524b26a

Years ago there was a guy on ebay making his own slabs and selling Spalding Guide cuts...that guy was prolific..I couldn't get his listings out of my saved searches.

[bcornell]

Originally Posted by slidekellyslide

Years ago there was a guy on ebay making his own slabs and selling Spalding Guide cuts...that guy was prolific..I couldn't get his listings out of my saved searches.

Libertyforall, aka Roy Huff. Lots of old posts about him - he may have invented retaliatory feedback towards buyers. Once eBay took that away, he and his book cut-outs disappeared.