Value? 1928 Giants Ball

[John V]

A neighbor friend has nice autographed ball of the New York Giants that belonged to his father-in-law. With magnifying glass in hand, I came up with the list below of signers. After review of the '27, '28 and '29 rosters, I've decided it is most likely from 1928. The ball is an Official National League with red and blue stitches. Many years ago, a fine gloss was applied.
He is considering having it certified. I would like to hear some thoughts from the board.

Barnes Virgil
Benton Larry
Bresnahan, Roger P (coach?)
Cantwell Ben
Clarkson Bill
Cohen Andy
Cummings, Jack
Faulkner Lefty
Fitzsimmons, Fred
Haeffner Wm
Harper Geo
Henry Frank
Hogan Frank
Jackson Travis
Jahn Art
Knowles Dr L. (team doc?)
Levy Jack
Lindstrom Freddie
Lobert Hans (coach?)
Mangum Leo
Mann Leslie
Mc Graw J.J.
Nichols Chet
O'Doul Frank
Ott Melvin
Reese Andy
Roush Edd
Spohrer Al
Terry Wm Bill
Walker Bill
Welsh Jim

[perezfan]

What type of thoughts are you seeking?

The Certification is nice to have if he's selling the ball. Obviously it's quite valuable if authentic, and most potential buyers would want a Letter. I would stick with PSA or JSA (as the two most valued opinions).

If he just wants the Certification for himself (and is not selling) then only he can determine if it's worth shelling out for the authentication fees. If he has any doubts about the signatures (or thinks some might be secretarial), then perhaps he should have it done.

Not sure if this helps... just my .02

[John V]

I realize I was not very clear about "thoughts". I appreciate your opinions on using either PSA or JSA. Although he probably not interested in selling, he might have some peace of mind with authentication.

[David Atkatz]

Put a few pics up here. The authenticity will be easy to determine. Absolutely no point in shelling out any money.

[John V]

Sorry for the so-so photos.

[John V]

.

[gashouse34]

Wow, amazing ball...it's definately the real deal imo....thanks for sharing

[khkco4bls]

john, red and black stitching.

[John V]

Originally Posted by khkco4bls

john, red and black stitching.

Oops! Red and black it is.

[esd10]

nice

[John V]

I have no experience with an autographed ball like this. I would greatly appreciate some opinions on value.
Thanks, John

[perezfan]

Value depends on the auction house or selling venue. There is a variance with all things like this but my guess would be $2,500 - $3,000.

The signatures are uniform and nice (as is the non-shellacked ball). This puts it among the best known examples for someone seeking a Giants ball of this vintage.

Best of luck!

[CMIZ5290]

John- for what it's worth, the mcgraw sig looks like the real deal. That is where alot of the value on the ball is.

[Mark]

Very nice. The signitures are in great shape for a ball from the 20's.