1938 Goudey Proof

[Jim VB]

Originally Posted by Bigb13

Can we can back to what this thread is about?

Asked and answered.

Originally Posted by Jim VB

I think Mike Baker of GAI has already given his answer. He says that the card was graded by the "old" GAI (of which he was President) and that company is now gone. He is now President of the "new" GAI and they hold no responsibility.

I would follow up with the seller, then Ebay and Paypal. If you used a credit card through Paypal, add them in the loop.

The card you received is not as described. That alone should get you a refund. You may need to have another grading company look at it (but don't crack it out of the slab) and give you an opinion. I suggest SGC.

What else do you want the board to do? Over a year ago Dan Mckee outed these cards as fakes. You didn't know and bought one. If you haven't paid, don't. If you have, take the steps necessary to get your money back.

In the meantime, don't rain on our parade when we have the best shot ever of laughing at all the Dorskinds.