Odds this Hal Chase is real?

[Archive]

Posted By: Scott Sarian

I was the seller of the PRO Chase card. I bought the card probably back 7 or 8 years ago, not knowing about PRO at the time. I stashed it away shortly thereafter to chalk it up as a lesson learned about PRO graded cards. I posted the card last week knowing that SGC and PSA "Authentic" cards still sell for a few bucks.

I wasn't trying to fool or deceive anyone in my listing, and specifically said in the listing "the top border looks a bit short, but nonetheless presents very nicely and is a great card to add to any vintage collection!" I am 100% sure the card is authentic, but feel similarly sure about it being trimmed on the top.

So the $100 it sold for is probably 1/2 or 1/3 of what I originally paid for it a while back, but probably represents a fair market value on what would most likely cross to an "A" grade.