Need help ID of three different Prewar cards or premiums...

[Archive]

Posted By: leon

I owned the Oodles chocolate fake card....bought it from a good seller on ebay and sent it to SGC where they deemed it counterfeit. I returned it and next thing I see it shows up on ebay in a PSA7 holder. The seller pulled the card as it should not have been in a holder. He said he actually sent it in by mistake with some others and it got holdered. I spoke with him at length at this last National (where I picked up a recent ebay win from him) and he told me there was a huge controversy at PSA about it. I absolutely believe this guy as he seems very honest (and did all the right things too) Something about a lawsuit and all kinds of crap after the fact. Really a big stink about it. It is fake and it did get into a PSA 7 holder. For the record, while I think they all make mistakes, I don't think too many fake cards get graded by the big 4 grading companies. This was a fluke they knew nothing about but really should have caught the weird paper. These cards all have that "rough" texture, and that is what made me think the Oodles was fake too. I have owned many fake cards and many of the 1928 era have the rough feel to them. regards

btw, the Oodles card didn't have the period gloss to it either...another telltale sign...