Seriously, how is this a 5?

[Archive]

Posted By: sagard

So to those who have held the card in their hand should it be a "3" or a "4"? Or was the "2" warranted?

It seems disappointing that both somewhat trusted grading companies would whiff by a full grade or more in opposite directions on the same card.

People hate buying overgraded cards. I would HATE to have sent that card in to SGC and find out later that almost any other day it would have got the VG grade.