E95 Break Up Value

[Archive]

Posted By: T206Collector

$338.33 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Christy Matthewson SGC card 10
$242.50 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Eddie Plank SGC Card 10
$224.50 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Frank Chance SGC Card 50
$560.00 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Honus Wagner SGC Card 20
$21.71 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Solly Hoffman SGC Card 20
$89.00 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Eddie Collins SGC Card 30
$92.99 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Johnny Evers SGC Card 30
$42.41 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Ed Reulbach SGC Card 30
$293.88 1909 E95 Philly Black Sox Caramel Ed Cicotte SGC 40
$109.16 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Harry Lord SGC Card 50
$21.66 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Tommy Leach SGC Card 20
$100.99 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Larry Doyle SGC Card 40
$32.87 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Hooks Wiltse SGC Card 30
$517.09 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Ty Cobb SGC Card 20
$129.83 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Sam Crawford SGC Card 20
$47.16 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Ed Willetts SGC Card 30
$148.66 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Art Devlin SGC Card 60
$37.56 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Matty McIntyre SGC Card 10
$36.00 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Fred Merkle SGC Card 10
$34.58 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Harry Krause SGC Card 30
$89.88 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Chief Bender SGC Card 20
$22.73 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Cy Morgan SGC Card 20
$77.16 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Nick Maddox SGC Card 40
$52.00 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Vic Willis SGC Card 10
$20.50 1909 E95 Philly Caramel Bill Carrigan SGC Card 10

Final Total: 3,383.15

So, if the seller actually purchased the set for $4,000.00, the seller lost over $600 in about two week's time by breaking it up. Of course, if the seller had better feedback, used better photos (or better yet, scans) and had not listed the auction for Monday evening, prices would likely have been higher.

Thus endeth the lesson.