GAI Quality

[Archive]

Posted By: Jerry Ficchi

I have recently returned to the hobby after a long layoff (my departure came soon after the founding of PSA) and was wondering about your experiences with holders. I understand the grading characteristics of each of the big three houses, as well as the perception of each when it comes to resale. My query rests solely in the holder for the time being. Aesthetically, I prefer GAI to PSA and SGC. Some have hinted of their concerns with GAI’s holder. Could you please elaborate? Additionally, I’ve recognized that PSA now uses some sort of “baggie” within its holder. Could anyone explain why they’ve come to use them? To me, it’s a complete turn off. The cards are askew and there is no contrast background whatsoever.

Since my focus will remain relatively narrow, specifically limited to a few issues between 1930 to 1950 of a few cards and players I enjoy, I would like to maintain some congruency with their holders. This leads me to a crossover question. How consistent have the companies, mainly GAI, been in maintaining grades when reslabbing?

Thank you for your kind help with this as well as your expertise within all threads.