1910 D322 Wagner

[Archive]

Posted By: BOTN

Scott,

I am not defending GAI or SGC on my E95 but I hardly think that one example warrants hanging these guys. You may want to relax. Grading companies make mistakes. They are run by humans. I make mistakes everyday. I am glad that I am not under the same scrutiny that the grading companies are and that you are not watching my every move. I would probably end up slitting my wrists for feeling like a complete failure. It takes backbone to admit when you are wrong. SGC did that and is taking care of the problem.

JC,

I consider myself a master at the grading game. I have been cracking cards out of holders for more than 3 years now-a concept that many dealers just learned about. When 99.9% of the dealers were only using PSA, I was using SGC, PSA and BGS. I broke the Wagner out as I thought that I had a great shot at getting a 2.5. The half grade does very well for me and is more accurate in grading. The fact that both companies graded it as Good, works for me and reinforces why I use both of them. Although I still contend that the card is under graded, despite the creases.