1st generation SGC Holders?

[Archive]

Posted By: leon

I think the concern is that there is a perception, and possibly reality, that older SGC graded cards were done more leniently, as were PSA cards. From my short experience it is a warranted concern. I had one of my high end cards crossed over into a new holder and it came back the same as the old holder. I am sure that is not always the case and is not a given. If re-submitted I am fairly sure SGC would grade them by todays standards and they may or may not hold up. My recommendation, for what it's worth, would be to only resubmit the cards you really think would hold up to todays standards....otherwise, I would leave them in the old ones.....that's just me though....good luck...and thanks for the nudging (BCD) to get that one reholdered.....I am glad I did....