T205 Question

[nebboy]

Errors for recognized 221-card master set - underlined are tuff ones

209. Hal Chase (baseline extends down)
210. Otis Crandall (‘T’ uncrossed)
211. Patsy Dougherty (red sock)
212. Dolly Gray (with stats)
213. Dick Hoblitzell (1908 No. Cin.)
214. Dick Hoblitzell (name misspelled)
215. Dick Hoblitzell (no stats)
216. A. Latham (W.A. on back)
217. A. Leifield (A.P. in signature)
218. Christy Mathewson (one loss Cycle back)
219. Pat Moran (stray line of text)
220. Bobby Wallace (one 1910 stat line)
221. Irwin Wilhelm (‘suffered’)
222. Eddie Collins (yellow elephant)
223. George Graham (black signature)
224. Danny Hoffman (yellow base, no stripe)
225. Danny Hoffman (yellow base with stripe)
226. A. Latham (.A. on back with a faint M before it)
227. Dots Miller (middle initial ‘D.’)
228. Dots Miller (middle initial combination of ‘B.’ and ‘D.’)
229. Fred Snodgrass (missing decimal point)
230. John Titus (stray print mark on Piedmont Factory 25 cards)
231. Ed Walsh (pink printing)
232. Doc White (no quotes)

[dabbuu]

I've been collecting this set for years

I have found this to be by far one of the hardest cards in the master set

225. Danny Hoffman (yellow base with stripe)

Originally Posted by nebboy

Errors for recognized 221-card master set - underlined are tuff ones

209. Hal Chase (baseline extends down)
210. Otis Crandall (‘T’ uncrossed)
211. Patsy Dougherty (red sock)
212. Dolly Gray (with stats)
213. Dick Hoblitzell (1908 No. Cin.)
214. Dick Hoblitzell (name misspelled)
215. Dick Hoblitzell (no stats)
216. A. Latham (W.A. on back)
217. A. Leifield (A.P. in signature)
218. Christy Mathewson (one loss Cycle back)
219. Pat Moran (stray line of text)
220. Bobby Wallace (one 1910 stat line)
221. Irwin Wilhelm (‘suffered’)
222. Eddie Collins (yellow elephant)
223. George Graham (black signature)
224. Danny Hoffman (yellow base, no stripe)
225. Danny Hoffman (yellow base with stripe)
226. A. Latham (.A. on back with a faint M before it)
227. Dots Miller (middle initial ‘D.’)
228. Dots Miller (middle initial combination of ‘B.’ and ‘D.’)
229. Fred Snodgrass (missing decimal point)
230. John Titus (stray print mark on Piedmont Factory 25 cards)
231. Ed Walsh (pink printing)
232. Doc White (no quotes)

[1956 Fan]

Originally Posted by nebboy

Errors for recognized 221-card master set - underlined are tuff ones

209. Hal Chase (baseline extends down)
210. Otis Crandall (‘T’ uncrossed)
211. Patsy Dougherty (red sock)
212. Dolly Gray (with stats)
213. Dick Hoblitzell (1908 No. Cin.)
214. Dick Hoblitzell (name misspelled)
215. Dick Hoblitzell (no stats)
216. A. Latham (W.A. on back)
217. A. Leifield (A.P. in signature)
218. Christy Mathewson (one loss Cycle back)
219. Pat Moran (stray line of text)
220. Bobby Wallace (one 1910 stat line)
221. Irwin Wilhelm (‘suffered’)
222. Eddie Collins (yellow elephant)
223. George Graham (black signature)
224. Danny Hoffman (yellow base, no stripe)
225. Danny Hoffman (yellow base with stripe)
226. A. Latham (.A. on back with a faint M before it)
227. Dots Miller (middle initial ‘D.’)
228. Dots Miller (middle initial combination of ‘B.’ and ‘D.’)
229. Fred Snodgrass (missing decimal point)
230. John Titus (stray print mark on Piedmont Factory 25 cards)
231. Ed Walsh (pink printing)
232. Doc White (no quotes)

Much appreciated. Thank you

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by nebboy

Errors for recognized 221-card master set - underlined are tuff ones

209. Hal Chase (baseline extends down)
210. Otis Crandall (‘T’ uncrossed)
211. Patsy Dougherty (red sock)
212. Dolly Gray (with stats)
213. Dick Hoblitzell (1908 No. Cin.)
214. Dick Hoblitzell (name misspelled)
215. Dick Hoblitzell (no stats)
216. A. Latham (W.A. on back)
217. A. Leifield (A.P. in signature)
218. Christy Mathewson (one loss Cycle back)
219. Pat Moran (stray line of text)
220. Bobby Wallace (one 1910 stat line)
221. Irwin Wilhelm (‘suffered’)
222. Eddie Collins (yellow elephant)
223. George Graham (black signature)
224. Danny Hoffman (yellow base, no stripe)
225. Danny Hoffman (yellow base with stripe)
226. A. Latham (.A. on back with a faint M before it)
227. Dots Miller (middle initial ‘D.’)
228. Dots Miller (middle initial combination of ‘B.’ and ‘D.’)
229. Fred Snodgrass (missing decimal point)
230. John Titus (stray print mark on Piedmont Factory 25 cards)
231. Ed Walsh (pink printing)
232. Doc White (no quotes)

So is the T205 master set really 232 instead of 221?

[BabyRuth]

I always loved this Eddie Collins with a second Blue elephant

[Leon]

Originally Posted by jayshum

So is the T205 master set really 232 instead of 221?

I am sure it depends on how far you want to take it
If i were doing the set I would stick to the recognized errors. Others will know more.
.

[HercDriver]

Don’t forget the one Mac W (obcmac) found a few years ago, where Phelps can be found with either a .224 BA, or a .234 BA. It’s a legitimate error, not a printing variant. The thread is on here somewhere with scans, if you don’t know about that one.

[doug.goodman]

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=329216

Phelps thread