Players not yet eligible for the HOF

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

WIth his WAR and BA, he's not making the Hall either way.

You're probably right, but that's what would make it interesting to see what happens if he did actually get to 500 home runs.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by Tomi

So we're Jim Rice and Dick Allen.

I am not saying Kent is not deserving, but Rice and Allen were both for at least modest periods close to the best power hitters in the game.

[G1911]

Most homers, 2nd in slugging and RBI to Hornsby, 4th in OPS. Even with the slow start to his career Kent turned out very well and is so high up the 2B leaderboards it seems difficult to justify keeping him out over his late start, but performance is now secondary to narratives. Ortiz is let in with a positive steroid test while the others like him are not given the same treatment, Schilling is kept out for politics, Kent is out for being undesirable, Vizquel is out over a civil claim with no publicly available evidence, the vets committee appears to have reached Frisch era corruption of picking friends. Performance is a lot less relevant than it was 30 years ago. Makes it more difficult to pick who will or won’t among current players that will be up for votes in another decade plus - it will probably have as much as to do with narratives not about actual performance as it does anything definable.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Whitaker IMO even more deserving than Kent. And of course there's the case of Grich.

[BioCRN]

Contemporary ballot coming up this year (for the 2026 HOF class).

Now is the time for baseball to make up for the absolute disrespect of Kenny Lofton being a 1-and-done ballot HOF candidate.

If not for playing vs roiders, he would have been a lot more impressive compared to his peers and more than 6 All-Star selections.

[Greg Sonk]

Kent is one of those guys that shows much better in pure counting stats than modern ones. As soon as you start to take the era he played in into account, his case gets quite a bit worse.

I'm sure the off field stuff doesn't help, but it's not the only reason.

[Peter_Spaeth]

2nd base JAWS rankings

8 Grich
12 Utley
13 Whitaker
22 Kent