WWG DiMaggios -- are these the same card?

[tjisonline]

Well said Ryan. Who is to say SGC got it right?

So many cards have been regraded since 3rd party card grading companies were created plus nothing suggests this ‘36 WWG Joe D card has ever been altered. Ever since SGC was acquired by PSA, their min size not met requirements is as inconsistent as PSA’s. I wonder if SGC is using that Collector’s purchased software company’s tech for sizing during the grading process.

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Peter, I think that’s up to the AH and I don’t think either is wrong (or right). In my opinion, it’s not the AH’s job to disclose that competing companies had different opinions. What Al did with Jay’s helmet is admirable, but I don’t feel required.

I have no interest in going back and forth. I have said my peace and we will just disagree on this one.

On a personal note, I once had a t227 Cobb that sat in a PSA 3 (or something) flip. BODA posted that it used to be in an SGC A flip but stated they saw no evidence of alteration. When I consigned it a few years later, I did mention to the AH that according to BODA it was once in an SGC A flip and the AH did not mention that on that listing; they described the lot as a PSA 3, which is what it was. I feel very fine about that. So so many cards used to have different grades or designations in other TPG flips (or same TPG flips).