Added this new Bronko Nagurski

[jefferyepayne]

Originally Posted by DezHood

Joe, can we see the Nags 8? I've been there on the upgrade issue - what really makes it hard is sometimes the higher grade one (say a 5) goes for less than my 4, so of course I throw a bid in and win, then I have 2 cards and I still like the lower grade one, so I sell the higher grade one (for a loss of course after fees, etc.) - definitely a pattern I'm trying to repeat less....

If that's happening, you are not bidding on these correctly. I've had 4 Nags and never taken a loss on any of them. I could sell my PSA 5 for a profit right now ;-)

Also remember to not get hung up on the grade. Grading is an imperfect science and I see cards ALL THE TIME that don't belong in the holder they are in. Buy the card, not the slab!

jeff

[TanksAndSpartans]

Hi Jeff, I know - I get hung up on the grade sometimes. I need to trust myself when I think a lower grade card is nicer and ignore the higher graded one.

I also tend to have losses because I have no patience - I just auction off duplicates right away.

My examples aren't on Nags or high priced cards - I'm talking about 35 Chicle low numbered non HOFers - the prices have gotten really low! I just saw a PSA 7 sell around 120. Psa 4 cards get down around 40, similar for 5s and 6s - not sure if collectors are exiting this set or what, but it's definitely a better time to start collecting this set than when I started. I wish I could have gotten these prices at the beginning.

[jefferyepayne]

Originally Posted by DezHood

Hi Jeff, I know - I get hung up on the grade sometimes. I need to trust myself when I think a lower grade card is nicer and ignore the higher graded one.

I also tend to have losses because I have no patience - I just auction off duplicates right away.

My examples aren't on Nags or high priced cards - I'm talking about 35 Chicle low numbered non HOFers - the prices have gotten really low! I just saw a PSA 7 sell around 120. Psa 4 cards get down around 40, similar for 5s and 6s - not sure if collectors are exiting this set or what, but it's definitely a better time to start collecting this set than when I started. I wish I could have gotten these prices at the beginning.

I hear you on the Chicles. That's why as much as possible I try not to escalate prices above VCP on anything I buy. I'd rather wait for a price that's reasonable. Also the card market goes up and down just like any market. I'm a big believer that the Chicle set (and football in general!) will increase in value over time but like anything, there will be peaks and valleys. As it's impossible to time the market perfectly, I just try to buy stuff I think is a decent deal and sell doubles when I think the market is a bit crazy. Otherwise I hang onto them if I can afford it and wait for the market to come back.

With the stock market taking a huge hit this last quarter, ANY industry/hobby that relies upon disposable income will see a bit of a hit. There's just less disposable cash floating around out there. Cards are no different in my mind.

Final point is that when the stock market is hot, you get a lot of speculators showing up who are trying to buy and flip things on the rise. That's never a good time for collectors to purchase items. Now that the market has cooled, I'm seeing some really nice deals out there on some sets / items. I agree that now is the time to pick up some of those things you want that were overpriced before.

Always a fun conversation to talk about cards with respect to the economy / stock market as it adds a bit of a twist to collecting.

jeff

[wrestlingcardking]

Here is a pic of the graded panel I just got back

[captainfitz]

Reviving this old thread because I have another Bronko postcard like revmoran's...but someone wrote on the back of mine. I really gotta send this off to PSA at some point. It's been stored away in a binder for half a decade.



Really fun to see all the Bronko stuff in here!