eras committee candidates baseball HOF

[John1941]

Originally Posted by Tabe

.617
.804
.625
.691
.597
.648
.692
.881 (Carew)
.545
.699
.703

That's the OPS of the other 2B in the AL in 1973. The average OPS was .710. 9 out of 11 were below that, with one guy 165 below that.

His contemporaries sucked.

In post 121 and here, you claim that Grich had such a high WAR in 1973 because his contemporaries sucked.

The element in which WAR adjusts for a player's peers is Rpos. By that statistic, WAR gives Grich five runs in 1973. As I showed in post 161, that is perfectly normal for a second baseman. Exactly five of Grich's 78 runs above replacement in 1973 were due to his contemporaries' ability or lack thereof.

Your claim that Grich has a high WAR in 1973 because his contemporaries were trash is totally false. WAR gives Grich a 8.3 WAR in 1973 because he hit very well (1973 was a pitcher's year) and because he's given a lot of credit for his fielding - which is not unreasonable, given that in 1973 he made 5 errors and led the league in assists, putouts, and double plays.

By the way, if you want to see the year-by-year positional adjustments that WAR makes, this page lists the adjustments through 2017: https://www.baseball-reference.com/a...position.shtml