Which Outfield would you rather and why?

[G1911]

Originally Posted by Seven

Simple (or not so simple) question for the board here. You have a choice between either one of these outfields to build a team around. We assume that the players are at the peak of their playing ability, and in perfect health. Which do you choose and why?

Outfield A
Mickey Mantle
Ted Williams
Babe Ruth

Outfield B
Willie Mays
Hank Aaron
Barry Bonds

CF: Mantle over Mays, because it is stipulated perfect healthy and at peak performance. I'll take Willie 10 times out of 10 for a career, but with the boundaries set here, Mantle probably comes out just slightly better.

RF: Ruth over Aaron and it is not even close. Their peak performance is really not that close. Biggest gap is this one.

LF: Prime roid Bonds is better than Williams at peak value and arguably the greatest peak performance of all time. Probably by not as big a gap as Ruth over Aaron though.

So I think A very slightly edges it, but these are constructed very well to be very very close.