An opinion seller redefines "trimmed"

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Doug, I know it's the range of the magazine, but obviously this piece can be dated with a bit more precision than that. As I understand it a range is given when the piece can't be more specifically dated.

Good point Peter. And obviously this one can be narrowed down pretty close...

As a matter of fact the 1951 Yankees Team (and also the Giants) were first advertised in the December 1951 issue of Baseball Magazine.

Doug

[glynparson]

Zero issue with the dating they go by the catalogue designations on issues and that’s what it’s designated. As for grading it. They screwed the pooch there. This should never have received a numerical grade.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by glynparson

Zero issue with the dating they go by the catalogue designations on issues and that’s what it’s designated. As for grading it. They screwed the pooch there. This should never have received a numerical grade.

They did the same thing on a few others being sold by the same seller on ebay for amounts that are best described as slightly on the high side.