Let's play a game of guess the grades!

[Snowman]

I don't understand the viewpoint that they ought to both be the same grade. If these two cards were submitted both raw, together, to the same company, there is zero chance of them coming back with the same grade. At any TPG.

[Pat R]

For those that were curious the SGC was graded in September 2018.

[jethrod3]

Originally Posted by Snowman

I don't understand the viewpoint that they ought to both be the same grade. If these two cards were submitted both raw, together, to the same company, there is zero chance of them coming back with the same grade. At any TPG.

As Leon mentioned a couple of posts later, in my case I picked the same grade because I suspected that something was awry or that there was a slight misgrading. Since we all know that misgrading happens, there is definitely a greater chance than zero that they could come back that way! Even if two cards are identical or the same card sent in separately at different times to each company.