Collecting in the collections, outside the mainstream

[yanks87]

Originally Posted by steve B

49 Leaf does indeed have more than 3 different varieties. each color comes at least two ways, and some colors have very obvious differences that are always one of those ways but not the other.
And there are what I call "transitional types, where a card might have for instance variety1 of blue that usually goes with variety 1 of red, but some have blue 1 and red 2.
As far as I know the grading companied recognize none of them.

It's way more complex than I ever expected when I started putting together my visual spreadsheet, especially for such a small set.


Many sets have unrecognized differences, ranging from very obvious like the pink vs red 49 Leaf to very subtle or hard to spot stuff like different angles on the halftones (88 score) or different patterns to the glosscoat (93 upper deck)

In some ways I'd like to see their existence acknowledged by some hobby "authority" but in other ways I'd like them to remain sort of secret. Once that recognition comes, some will become expensive.

This is actually one that I am in the process of researching. Leaf presents an unusual issue. The ink colors that were used definitely had a pretty good spectrum, but there is more to it. I have a theory that there was a 2nd printing of the first 49 in the set, with changes made to the printing plate. These plate changes have been verified with people within the printmaking trade who are familiar with the letter press that the cards were printed on. In this instance, it would be a variation akin to the Demmitt, Eberfield or Doyle T206's as there was an actual plate change. As far as I can tell, of the populations, ~35% of the population are actually from the 2nd printing. The pink you refer to, was actually from that second printing.

SO, does this mean that the variations from that printing are worth more, because they are more scarce? I guess time will tell.

[steve B]

Originally Posted by yanks87

This is actually one that I am in the process of researching. Leaf presents an unusual issue. The ink colors that were used definitely had a pretty good spectrum, but there is more to it. I have a theory that there was a 2nd printing of the first 49 in the set, with changes made to the printing plate. These plate changes have been verified with people within the printmaking trade who are familiar with the letter press that the cards were printed on. In this instance, it would be a variation akin to the Demmitt, Eberfield or Doyle T206's as there was an actual plate change. As far as I can tell, of the populations, ~35% of the population are actually from the 2nd printing. The pink you refer to, was actually from that second printing.

SO, does this mean that the variations from that printing are worth more, because they are more scarce? I guess time will tell.

There are absolutely differences in all four plates, possibly more than 2 versions of each.

As far as I can tell, they're not letterpress, but lithographed.
At least 3 distinct press runs of the 49, probably more.
If it was all about rarity, some would be worth more the pink ones are not as common as the others. The transitional types may turn out to be truly rare/uncommon.
The problem with value is that enough people have to both know and care for there to be enough demand.
With most errors or variations that just doesn't happen.


I'll have to upload the current version, but I'm gradually saving images of all the differences I can spot, and have most of them on a spreadsheet. It won't email, but I can send you a link.

[yanks87]

Steve,

just sent you a note. Agreed on all fronts, (and the wrong backs!).

[ALBB]

I think with a killer set like that Leaf set. Most collectors would be happy with any color variation of a card they need