Why is this considered altered?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by JollyElm

Houston...er, I mean, Leon...we have a problem. Looks like a scammer/spammer slipped in.

Taken care of.....they usually don't post in the middle of thread. Kind of ballsy
.

[BobC]

Originally Posted by Leon

Taken care of.....they usually don't post in the middle of thread. Kind of ballsy
.

Thanks as always Leon.

By the way, Darren's post #21 in this thread includes a copy of the scam post and link. I would advise removing that copied post and link as well.

[glchen]

The paper loss on the top corners may be due to the premium previously having been taped to something. Maybe there is still some tape residue in the corners which would have led to the Altered qualifier?

[Hordfest]

The saga is finally over. SGC has returned Mr. Williams and I figure it is fitting on his birthday to share this! What PSA saw I will never know, but I'm thankful SGC realized the truth that it was not an altered card.

The Trinity is complete! Now to find an auction house...

[fkm_bky]

Congratulations and good luck with the sale! They're beautiful cards!

Bill

[luciobar1980]

Why is this even a thing with cards? With comic books the graders will more-or-less tell you exactly what the alteration is. Why shouldn't card graders tell their customers the reason for such an assessment? It boggles my mind.

I think SGC did a great thing by at least now telling you the basic alteration they've detected.

[Lorewalker]

Originally Posted by luciobar1980

Why is this even a thing with cards? With comic books the graders will more-or-less tell you exactly what the alteration is. Why shouldn't card graders tell their customers the reason for such an assessment? It boggles my mind.

I think SGC did a great thing by at least now telling you the basic alteration they've detected.

In my jaded opinion it is about them avoiding being challenged on their findings. I would not expect them to take the time to inform us at the $30 level subs but think we are entitled to knowing their findings paying anything more than that.

SGC used to indicate on the card saver with a sharpie the area that resulted in a card being rejected, if they were returning in unslabbed.

Now TPG can just hide behind the fact that they are too busy to take the time. Again this all leads to less transparency, less value for your dollar and one more missed chance at being educated thereby making us better buyers and better submitters.