PWCC Exceptional/SGC 6.5 52 Topps card ..... or not

[Wanaselja]

Originally Posted by Johnny630

Peter this is such a Crock Of S&It

Authentic: Here's the true background story. I purchased this card back in January 2019 on Ebay in a PWCC auction. The card was slabbed in an SGC holder and graded EX-NM+ 6.5 as the scan shows above. PWCC also certified the card as having "EXCEPTIONAL eye appeal for the professional grade". Since my 1952 Topps set is all PSA graded, I felt confident in purchasing the card and sending it in to PSA to cross over so as to be consistent with the PSA Graded 1952 Topps set I am assembling. To my shock and dismay, the card came back as altered. I sent it into PSA a second time, hoping it was an oversight or the grader was having a bad day. The card came back as altered again. Left with few alternatives, I recently decided to send it back to SGC in the hope that they would restore it to the EX-NM+ 6.5 in which it originally came. Unfortunately, it came back as A (Authentic) as the current picture shows. SGC too has now decided this time that the card was altered. So, bottom line, it's my loss. If you would like to purchase this card knowing the history for likely a fraction of what I paid for it, here is your opportunity.
Buyer to add $10 for USPS shipping and insurance.

To bad you crack out you own it. This story is ridiculous, I believe none of it. See the top right dip in the sgc A slab you fool! You did something to it. Nah Dude you’re full of shit.

So the entire listing and story was fabricated to make a few extra bucks? Also, the “dip” exists in both.