Rare, Original Holmes to Homes Ty Cobb Hits Market

[dbrown]

seller's bowman & topps Mantle are fake too. shocking!

[bbnut]

How do you know the Mantles are fake? Look reasonably legit to me, but maybe I'm missing something. Suspicious with the price, for sure, but I can't see (or know what) the signs are. Would appreciate the tell-tale signs.

[Yastrzemski Sports]

Isn't there an unwritten rule about outing a live auction? I was going to jump on that.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Yastrzemski Sports

Isn't there an unwritten rule about outing a live auction? I was going to jump on that.

Not only did we out a card we probably also got a current bidder to back out.

That would have been the worst 50 bucks that person had ever spent.

[dbrown]

The signs for the fake Mantles are mostly in the wear on the cards -- if you look at the back of the Bowman, you see "crazing" lines with some tone coming through. I've ONLY seen that kind of wear on artificially aged fakes -- you see some of the same kind of wear on the front of the Cobb. The edge wear is terrible, too -- hard to articulate, but it's not what you see on vintage 1950s card stock. At the bottom, you can see how the white-ish color of the back is wearing off, which it should not -- that color should be part of the cardboard itself.

compare to (a random image find) this real card with some wear: https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/12...g?v=1528823538

on the 1960 there are fewer red flags but the image quality is terrible -- see Mantle's head/hat, the blacks are all running into a big mess, vs. the clear, subtly toned original.

Also they both appear to be hand cut on at least one edge?